Hi Côme,

> This example is really confusing me more than anything else.


Thank you very much for your feedback.  You illustrated perfectly why I should 
not have produced that proposal in haste.

Your confusion was due to my first draft errors, which thanks to your feedback 
I have hopefully had a chance to correct. I effectively rewrote and extended 
the proposal which you should be able to find at the same URL:

https://gist.github.com/mikeschinkel/50aec7094f5643223d28674639f9f117 
<https://gist.github.com/mikeschinkel/50aec7094f5643223d28674639f9f117>

I would be greatly appreciative if you could give is a second look.


> All in all I do not understand the benefits of this approach compared to 
> Nikita’s RFC.

I have moved the benefits to the beginning of the document and expanded the 
list I elaborate on. 

Hopefully they will be clear now?


-Mike Schinkel

P.S. Someone graciously emailed me off list and mentioned that my comments 
regarding Nikitia sounded like a criticism. If anyone else thought the same — 
and especially Nikita — please understand I was attempting to praise him but 
trying to do so in a humorous manner. 

As the person who emailed me made me realize, sometimes my humor may not 
translate via a mailing list and especially not for those who are not native 
English speakers. So I will do my best to avoid using humor on the list in the 
future.  

To be clear, I am in awe of Nikita and both his abilities and efforts to 
benefit the PHP community and greatly appreciate his efforts. I hope that 
clarifies my earlier intent.


> On Sep 5, 2019, at 4:51 AM, Côme Chilliet  wrote:
> 
> Why does the class Number in the example has a $number property and use 
> $this->number->value() rather than $this->value() ?
> 
> What is the difference between its getNumber method and its value method?
> 
> Is $this->number and $this->number->number pointing the same object or is 
> $this->number->number NULL?
> 
> This example is really confusing me more than anything else.
> 
> The "function showNumber" example is using $this->number instead of $number I 
> think.
> 
> All in all I do not understand the benefits of this approach compared to 
> Nikita’s RFC.
> What does this allow you to do that you cannot do without?
> 
> Côme

Reply via email to