http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/home/how-a-molehill-grew-into-a-mountain-of-intolerance/479254

How a Molehill Grew Into a Mountain of Intolerance
Vento Saudale | November 17, 2011


Bogor. It’s been almost a year since he was found guilty of falsifying 
signatures in a case that led to the troubles of the embattled GKI Yasmin 
Church, but local resident Munir Karta remains adamant that he is innocent. 

The Bogor District Court ruled on Jan. 20 that Munir was guilty of falsifying 
10 signatures on a letter attesting that residents in Curug Mekar ward had no 
objections to the construction of the church there. 

“By God, I have not falsified signatures in that letter. The 10 signatures on 
that letter are all original,” Munir said, speaking at his residence in Curug 
Mekar. 

That court ruling has been used by Bogor municipal authorities to revoke the 
construction permit for the Yasmin church, leading to the prolonged battle that 
has played out in the media at home, and occasionally abroad. 

The Supreme Court has since ruled that Bogor authorities should restore the 
permit to the church, but the city’s mayor, Diani Budiarto, has refused to do 
so. 

The case is one of several cited by activists as signs that intolerance in 
Indonesia is growing as people become increasingly exposed to fundamentalism. 

Munir said his signing of a police deposition was made under pressure at the 
Bogor police station in the presence of several people from a hard-line 
religious organization, the Indonesia Muslim Communication Forum (Forkami). 

“I was all alone seated there [at the police station] and was forced to follow 
what [Forkami] members said, and I now regret that,” he said. 

Munir said that while initially the 63 families in Curug Mekar were split about 
the plans to build the church nearby, opposition to the project has since 
waned. 

“Now residents do not object to, or feel they are disturbed by, the Yasmin 
church considering that the distance between the village and the church is 
quite far, about 1.5 kilometers,” he said. 

He also said those people who had protested against the construction of the 
church there were not all local residents and that he did not expect the case 
became so high-profile. 

“Not even one of our residents took part in the protests. Whatever the 
decision, to move or stay there, what is important is that the matter be 
settled,” he said. 

Munir also said he regretted being part of the problem afflicting the Yasmin 
church. He said he never thought giving in to the pressure of the Forkami 
members would carry such significant consequences. 

“I regret it, had I known it would come to this,” he said. 

Munir also denied rumors that accused him of having received money from the 
church to falsify the signatures. 

“If I had accepted money, my home would not be as small as this,” he said. 

For more than a year, members of the GKI Yasmin Church in Bogor have been 
forced to pray on the street. 

In an open letter sent to US President Barack Obama on Monday, the United 
States Commission on International Religious Freedom called on Obama to speak 
out against Indonesia’s growing religious tensions during the upcoming Asean 
Summit in Bali. 

New York-based Human Rights Watch also urged Obama to discuss human rights 
challenges in Indonesia, including attacks on religious minorities, 
restrictions on freedom of expression, and the lack of accountability of 
security forces for human rights abuses. 

“Obama needs to temper his past praise of religious tolerance in Indonesia with 
some tough talk on religious freedom,” HRW’s Elaine Pearson said. “He should 
press President [Susilo Bambang] Yudhoyono to end discriminatory laws and 
actively protect the country’s religious minorities.”

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke