For the record, I have ALWAYS been willing to send points of view I may or may not disagree with, GIVEN they are reasoned and well stated.
Dave ---------------------------- Original Message ---------------------------- Subject: Fwd: CDT Calls for Legislation to Preserve Internet Neutrality From: "John Morris" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Date: Tue, June 20, 2006 9:50 am To: "David Farber" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dave, Although we reach a different conclusion than you do on the "neutrality" debates, your IP readers might be interested in a paper that CDT just released supporting a narrow approach to "Internet neutrality". Our paper, available at http://www.cdt.org/speech/20060620neutrality.pdf, is summarized in the release below. Also included below is a link to a paper that CDT commissioned by MIT's Danny Weitzner, taking a look at the net neutraltiy issues from a technologist's perspective. John Morris Center for Democracy & Technology At 9:00 AM -0400 6/20/06, David McGuire wrote: >CDT Calls for Legislation to Preserve Internet Neutrality > >WASHINGTON -- June 20, 2006 -- The Center for Democracy and >Technology (CDT) today called on lawmakers to enact narrowly >tailored legislation to preserve the essential neutrality and >openness of the Internet, while leaving broadband network providers >free to experiment with non-neutral arrangements elsewhere on their >networks. > >The Internet is fundamentally neutral, and that neutrality has been >critical to its unique role as an engine for free speech and >innovation, CDT finds in a new paper >(http://www.cdt.org/speech/20060620neutrality.pdf). In the >narrowband world, adherence to that neutrality was widely accepted. >When Congress first permitted commercial traffic on the Internet, it >did so with the understanding that information providers would be >treated equally. > >But as new broadband networks evolve, recent legal decisions, >regulatory changes, announcements by network owners and a >consolidating market have put that essential neutrality at >significant risk. > >"The open and neutral Internet is a unique engine of free >expression, innovation and commerce. CDT has long promoted and >defended the Internet as a true technology of freedom. We cannot >take risks with its future," CDT Executive Director Leslie Harris >said. "Once new, non-neutral networks and business arrangements have >been put in place on the Internet, overturning those arrangements is >likely to be extremely difficult. If the telecom bill happens this >year, net neutrality language must be included. It is better to >establish rules of the road in advance, so that neutrality will be >factored into network architecture and business plans from the >start." > >CDT reached its conclusions after months of careful study and >consultation with stakeholders from all sides of the debate. As part >of that process, CDT commissioned a separate paper on the subject by >Daniel Weitzner, available here >http://dig.csail.mit.edu/2006/06/neutralnet.html . > >In its paper, CDT makes five key findings: 1) today's Internet is >neutral in a number of crucial ways; 2) neutrality is rooted in the >Internet's history and has been central to its development as a tool >for innovation and free expression; 3) the future of that essential >neutrality is uncertain -- endangered by regulatory and commercial >developments that open the door for discriminatory behavior by >network providers; 4) legislation is warranted; and 5) legislation >should take a narrow approach that focuses on Internet neutrality, >rather than the broader question of "network neutrality," and does >so in the least restrictive, yet still effective way. > >CDT found that it is vital to make a clear distinction between >"Internet neutrality" and the more ambiguous principle of "network >neutrality." The broadband networks that would be affected by >neutrality legislation also carry cable television and other >non-Internet services over much of their bandwidth. CDT believes >that current legislation should be focused specifically on the >portion of broadband networks dedicated to the Internet. For the >portion of the network not devoted to the Internet, CDT believes >that legislation should require regular monitoring and reporting to >ensure that as new services are deployed, they do not crowd or >undermine the neutral Internet. > >"Whatever Congress decides on this issue will affect the Internet >for decades to come," CDT Staff Counsel David Sohn said. "If we can >get the right rules in place, it will help ensure that the Internet >remains a tool for democracy, industry and expression for new >generations of users." > >Added Sohn: "We need to move forward legislatively but we also need >dialogue to ensure that we get it right. We don't want to impede the >growth of new broadband networks or intrude into their non-Internet >operations, but legislation that simply sets out consumer rights >without prohibiting discriminatory treatment falls short of the mark >in protecting the essential Internet. Such an approach would give >the FCC too much discretion and too little guidance. We believe that >net neutrality rules need to be clear in the statute so that the >Commission is in an enforcement role, not a regulatory one. We >intend to work with all parties to perfect legislation as the >process moves forward." > >About CDT: The Center for Democracy and Technology works to promote >democratic values and constitutional liberties in the digital age. >With expertise in law, technology, and policy, CDT seeks practical >solutions to enhance free expression and privacy in global >communications technologies. CDT is dedicated to building consensus >among all parties interested in the future of the Internet and other >new communications media. > >--30-- > >-- >-------------------------------------------------- >David McGuire >Director of Communications >Center for Democracy & Technology >(202) 637 9800 x106 >(202) 423 7432 (mob) >-------------------------------------------------- >_______________________________________________ >http://www.cdt.org/mailman/listinfo/update ------------------------------------- You are subscribed as [email protected] To manage your subscription, go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/?listname=ip Archives at: http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/
