Web server manager wrote:

>>
>>>In particular, does
>>>
>>>block in quick on xl1 from any to any
>>>pass out quick on xl1 proto tcp from any to any flags S keep state keep frags
>>>pass out quick on xl1 proto udp from any to any keep state
>>>pass out quick on xl1 proto icmp from any to any keep state
>>>
>>>allow in icmp-type 3 code 4 for a stateful tcp connection?
>>>
>>Yes.
>>
> 
> Are you sure about that? When we started using IP Filter recently (V3.4.25, on 
> Solaris 2), I thought the same but rapidly found that it wasn't really true, 
> with a proportion of such ICMPs being logged as blocked. I assumed that was 
> because the ICMPs were from intermediate "infrastructure" (routers, terminal 
> server sending source quench for a saturated dialup connection, etc.) rather 
> than the end-point recorded by "keep state" - the log entries identified the 
> sources and that explanation certainly seemed to fit. Does that sound
> reasonable? Or should the ICMP still have been recognised, so that the
> blocking implies something else was wrong?


Depends what you mean by "am I sure".. =)

I'm sure that IP Filter *should* have let them pass. There are a variety of 
reasons it may not have, the most likely being lag time.

Albeit I've not delved into the code, I understand that IPF does have the 
ability to recognize all of these cases.


> Our configuration files are currently allowing echo, squench, redir, 
> unreach, and timex in explicitly, plus any other ICMP that's recognisably 
> associated with stateful TCP connections.


I don't allow any of these explicitly, but they all come through for me. Then 
again I'm on a small home network. At my old job, IPF guarded a small internal 
network with no servers, and I was asked to put a server behind it before I 
left (the company more or less when out of business, so all our servers in the 
datacenter became one server housed locally - don't ask me why)... but I never 
got to look at the effects of that...

Phil
-- 
"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety 
deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-Benjamin Franklin, 1759

Reply via email to