Hi Margaret, Had time to read this spec in more detail. Very well written and good integration of IP with 3GPP details for recommendations. Design team should be proud of this spec and it is very useful to both the IP and 3GPP implementation communities which will overlap.
I do think this should be working group item per all the health warnings in the spec that this is a **recommendation** but should be on BCP track not standards track is my feeling. Specific comments: 1. I support ALL recommendations of feature supports for IPv6 in handsets and UE's. It is imperative that the principle of a cohesive code base for IPv6 from non-3GPP implementation be useful and as bug for bug compatible with wireline IPv6 implementations. This will also permit 3GPP implementations to use expediently the future IPv6 extensions as they are developed and permit a better sharing of implementation and interoperability between IPv6 wireline services with 3GPP services. 2. On /64 I support this. 3GPP implementations should be able to suppo0rt /64 and IMO /128 if necessary not doing so is short sighted for 3GPP implementations. 3. I do not think we should spend time in the IPv6 WG discussing how, what, or why 3GPP should support our indirect IPv6 policies (e.g. Site Local, Privacy, Use Models) for IPv6. This will be counter productive for the working group and hold up forwarding a technical recommendation. The policy used and supported by the 3GPP standards process and implementation community is their business and not ous here in the IETF standards process. For individuals or social views here that have policy input for 3GPP please go directly to 3GPP with that input is my suggestion. This will permit us to wrap this up quickly and not spend years working on it in the IETF. I think we need to do same work for 3GPP2 in addition to 3GPP. I have no issue with the technical recommendations and they should be sent to 3GPP as soon as possible from this community. Again go BCP route not standards track. Good job and thanks /jim -------------------------------------------------------------------- IETF IPng Working Group Mailing List IPng Home Page: http://playground.sun.com/ipng FTP archive: ftp://playground.sun.com/pub/ipng Direct all administrative requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED] --------------------------------------------------------------------
