Hi Tero,

IKEv1 did allow sending payloads in any order, if I remember right.

Right, but with some restrictions (e.g. HASH Payload in QM must go before other Payloads).

Hmm... funny typo in section 1:

  o  User wants to get anonymous access to some resource.  In this
     situation he/she should be able to authenticate server, but to
     leave out his/her own authentication to prevent anonymity.  In
     this case one-way authentication is desirable.

user will leave out authentication to PREVENT anonymity... I assume
preserve is the one word that was meant...

Yes, of course. Thanks for catching.

And in -01 draft I've added one more use case:

  o  User wants to get some simple action from remote device.  Consider
     garage door opener: it must authenticate user to open the door,
     but it is not necessary for the user to authenticate the door
     opener.  In this case one-way authentication is sufficient.

In this example there is no harm if garage door opener
fills in its ID Payload - it need not be anonymous.

Regards,
Valery.
_______________________________________________
IPsec mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipsec

Reply via email to