Thomas Narten wrote:

[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:


Reading 2711, there are some host / server specific issues about 2711. Suggested text:


IPv6 Router Alert Option specific [RFC-2711] defines a new option in the


s/specific/specifically/?

IPv6 Hop-by-Hop Header. Hosts MAY support the router alert option defined. Nodes that generate RSVP message MUST implement the router
alert option. The Router Alert Option [RFC-2711] MUST be supported by nodes that perform packet forwarding at the IP layer (i.e. - the node is
a router).


Router alerts are also required with MLD messages. So wording that
reflects this would be good. Indeed, I don't think the RSVP usage is
so important to mention, given that RSVP isn't mentioned elsewhere in
the document. How about something like the following instead:

  The IPv6 Router Alert Option [RFC-2711] is an optional IPv6
  Hop-by-Hop Header that is used in conjunction with some protocols
  (e.g., RSVP [RFC XXX], or MLD [RFC XXX]). The Router Alert option
  will need to be implemented whenever protocols that mandate its
  usage are implemented.  See Section XXX-MLD.

I like Thomas' suggested text. Only mentioning RSVP with respect to the router alert option is the wrong approach.

Regards,
Brian


-------------------------------------------------------------------- IETF IPv6 working group mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] Administrative Requests: https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6 --------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to