On Thu, Jul 01, 2004 at 07:48:29AM +1000, Geoff Huston wrote:
>
> As this is a working group document I would like to understand on what
> basis this decision was taken. I could be mistaken here but I would've
> thought that it would be reasonable for the working group chairs to seek
> the views of the working group before making changes to a working group
> document. The basis for my concern here is that I see this splitting of the
> document into two as an action that appears to take a fundamental problem
> of assured address uniqueness and turns it into what could be loosely
> characterized as a random free-for-all. I'm personally unconvinced that
> what appears from the outside to be short term expediency on the part of
> the WG Chairs should be an acceptable substitute for, at the very least,
> seeking the views of the working group prior to making such decisions.
Geoff,
The pre-split draft had both unique ("registry assured") and probabilisticly
unique ("random") prefix generation methods, so I don't think the split of
the draft is creating a new problem as such. As one of the people who was
in favour of the split (back at Minneapolis) I didn't like a draft titled
"Unique Local" having a method included that might not offer a unique local
prefix. So I think the split is useful in that respect.
If it stayed as one draft, a title change would have been appropriate (e.g.
Obtaining IPv6 Prefixes for Local Address Domains" or something like that).
Tim
--------------------------------------------------------------------
IETF IPv6 working group mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Administrative Requests: https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6
--------------------------------------------------------------------