Mark Andrews wrote:
Dan Lanciani wrote:

Brian E Carpenter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

|But I agree with the conclusion, since I don't think
|either kind of ULA has any business in the global DNS.

Are you including the forward DNS in that statement?  I would be opposed
to dicouraging such use since it would imply the need for split DNS.  As
I've mentioned in the past, I have nothing against split DNS per se, but
I certainly would not want to _require_ it and I do not wish to use it
myself.

Well, people who want to use ULAs as obscurity addresses will not put them in public DNS, either forward or reverse. And if they do appear as AAAA records in public DNS, they will be unrouteable. It seems like a bad idea to have unrouteable addresses published, since they will complicate address selection for no benefit. So while not wanting to require split DNS, I think we have to expect a lot of it (as there is a great deal of it today).

Brian


        No. The addresses are not routable *everywhere*.  Being unique
        they are no worse than any other address that is partially
        filtered.  Connections will either succeed or fail.

Academically, that's true. Pragmatically, they are unrouteable outside the corporate firewall in almost all cases. So including them in address selection is a Bad Thing operationally, because it will lead to failed connection attempts and retries on an alternative address. Which is why I expect most enterprises will not export them into global DNS.

   Brian

--------------------------------------------------------------------
IETF IPv6 working group mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Administrative Requests: https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to