>>>>> On Mon, 9 May 2005 10:56:35 -0400, 
>>>>> Brian Haberman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said:

>       A refreshed version of the ICMP Name Lookups draft is available.
> I would especially like WG members who have implementations to
> review the draft and point out discrepancies between the spec and
> their code (e.g. unimplemented features).

Thanks for your effort of revising the document.  I've reviewed the
latest draft, and have some comments.  (I must confess in advance that
I don't fully remember the past discussions on this document, and that
I may be repeating points already discussed before.)

Regarding discrepancy with our (KAME/BSD) implementation, whereas I've
not done "line-by-line" checks between the spec and the implementation,
it seems the implementation supports all the features described in the
latest draft type/code/Qtype-wise.

However,
  - our implementation currently does NOT delay the response to an
    anycasted or multicasted query.
  - it does NOT support the proxy responder service.
  - it still supports the "Supported Qtypes" Qtype which is now marked
    as "unused" (as far as I know this is just because we've not fully
    followed recent changes of the spec).

Other general comments follow:

1. In section 2, this document is too specific about particular
   implementations:

     [...]  An example of a IPv6 debugging tool using IPv6 Node
     Information Queries is the ping6 program in the KAME, USAGI, and
     other IPv6 implementations <http://www.kame.net>.

   I'm afraid this is not very appropriate for a general specification
   document.  Instead, we might say:

     [...]  An example of an IPv6 debugging tool using IPv6 Node
     Information Queries is the ping6 program in some platforms.

2. it seems to me that the notion of "proxy" is suddenly introduced in
   Section 5.  I think it should be clearly defined beforehand, e.g.,
   in Section 3.

3. In Section 3, the draft reads:

     The Query concerns a "Subject Address" (which may
     differ from the Queried Address) or a "Subject Name".

   We may also want to note that the Subject Address is not even an
   IPv6 address (i.e., it can be an IPv4 address).

4. I'm afraid the reference to the MD5 spec (RFC1321) in Section 5
   should be a normative reference in this context.  (If
   icmp-name-lookups is expected to be published as a PS, this may
   cause a problem since RFC1321 is informational.)

5. I don't see why we need the TTL field for Node Name, Node
   Addresses, and IPv4 Addresses if it MUST be always 0.  Perhaps this
   is just for backward compatibility to existing implementations,
   though...(if so, I believe we should explicitly note that, since
   otherwise future readers will have the same question)

6. In section 5, the draft reads:

     [...]  If the
     Queried Address was anycast or multicast, the source address for the
     Reply SHOULD be one belonging to the interface on which the Query was
     received.

   I don't see the strong reason in this case for choosing the source
   address on the receiving interface.  If we need to give guidance
   about the source address in these cases, I think we can (or even
   should) just refer to RFC3484.

7. Should we still need the "S" and "C" flags for the Node Addresses
   Query even though site-local unicast addresses and IPv4-compatible
   IPv6 addresses are now deprecated?

8. RFC2535 (DNSSEC) was updated by RFC4033-4035.  We may want to
   update the reference as well.

And here are some editorial comments:

(throughout the document)
"a NI" should be "an NI"?  (depending on how we pronounce the acronym,
of course).

(section 2)
   [...]  An example of a IPv6 debugging tool using IPv6 Node
=> An example of an IPv6 debugging tool...

(section 5)
   Providing the infrastructure to authenticate NI Queries and Replies
   may be quote difficult outside of a well-defined community.
=>
   ... may be quite difficult(?)

(section 6.3)
   [...]  The Reply Data is a sequence of 128-bit IPv6
   addresses, each address preceded by separate a 32-bit TTL value, with
=> ... by a separate 32-bit TTL value (?)

(section 7)
   The IANA is requested to assign the IPv6 multicast prefix FF02:0:0:0:
   0:2::/96 for use in Node Information Queries as defined in section
   Section 5.
=> ... in Section 5.
  (i.e., remove the redundant "section")

                                        JINMEI, Tatuya
                                        Communication Platform Lab.
                                        Corporate R&D Center, Toshiba Corp.
                                        [EMAIL PROTECTED]

--------------------------------------------------------------------
IETF IPv6 working group mailing list
[email protected]
Administrative Requests: https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to