Hi Jari, >Tim, > > >> I agree that ULA-C "needs a home" but disagree the IPv6 Maintenance WG is >> it, given: >> >> * the first paragraph of the proposed charter: >> >> "The sole purpose of this group is in the maintenance of the core >> IPv6 protocol specifications and *not* in the development of new >> solutions or changes to the specifications.." >> >> && at least one of the group chairs doesn't consider it to be a core >> protocol, >> >> && at least one of the group chairs doesn't see group consensus on ULA-C, >> >> && there are other group members who don't see group consensus on ULA-C, >> >> && we haven't heard from any group members who do see group consensus on >> ULA-C, >> >> && "Complete work" is meant to be predicated upon group consensus >> >> I'd say it should be removed from the charter. >> > >What we really want to achieve is to have a forum where we >can talk about maintenance issues of the IPv6 protocol set,
That is both the explicit and implicit curriculum here, I understand. >but we also need to carry over the work that remains from >IPv6 WG. Yes, I agree in principle, so would say the language of the charter needs to be modified. The "_sole_ purpose of this group" would then _not_ be "maintenance of the _core_ IPv6 protocol specifications. I am not creating another working group to >just talk about ULA, so we have a practical question of >where we will finish the work. Exactly. (And by "finish" I might >mean that we decide to abandon the work at the end -- >but NOT before a discussion.) > >Please be assured that we will not move the ULA work forward >if the current non-consensus situation does not change. Thank you. > >Brian Carpenter wrote: >> 6man, and tweak the charter to cover address architecture maintenance, > >This would be my take too. > >Jari Tim Enos Rom 8:28 -------------------------------------------------------------------- IETF IPv6 working group mailing list [email protected] Administrative Requests: https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6 --------------------------------------------------------------------
