On Weds 12th December, Remi Despres wrote, in part:
> Not sure however that the two proposed questions 
> are clear enough because today:
> - some IIDs have u = 0, and some have u = 1,
> - some IIDs have g = 0, and some have g = 1. 
> The only combination that isn't used is u=g=1.

While U==G==1 is not *widely deployed* today,
it does have a very clear definition, namely:

        (U==1 && G==1) defines a global-scope 
        multicast identifier.

This is clear not only from a plain-language
reading of RFC-4291, Section 2.5.1, but also 
from the IEEE 802 definition of an EUI-64.

Further, an IID formed by algorithmically translating
an IEEE 802 MAC Address (e.g. using RFC-4291,
Appendix A), whether using a unicast or multicast
MAC address, is a widely deployed example of an
"interface identifier with universal scope".

Yours,

Ran


--------------------------------------------------------------------
IETF IPv6 working group mailing list
[email protected]
Administrative Requests: https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to