On Fri, Dec 20, 2013 at 7:12 AM, Jeff Hardy <jdha...@gmail.com> wrote: > On Wed, Dec 18, 2013 at 4:49 AM, Pawel Jasinski > <pawel.jasin...@gmail.com> wrote: >> hi, >> >> I have managed to get pyzmq to work under Ironpython. >> Anybody interested can take it from: >> https://github.com/paweljasinski/pyzmq/tree/iron >> https://github.com/paweljasinski/clrzmq/tree/iron > > That's fantastic. I'm assuming this is for IPython Notebook?
actually I have tested it with ptvs and ipython. I was able to enable "ipython w/o pylab" and get a session going. It is not a touch-down. The guilty is ip unicode/byte/char system. The ipython types are python 3 compatible, but entire standard lib is typed in 2.x terms. This is a strong argument to move to 3. For the ipython itself, modifications are ugly (I will push it to my github repo today). Not all usage scenarios of ipython/zmq work. There are unittest in ipython/zmq which I simply gave up. > >> It is usable, but not in the "push request" quality. >> >> I would appreciate feedback about a way clrzmq is integrated with ironpython. >> In order to keep structure of the pyzmq, native C# modules must >> reference things from python. > > I doubt adding IP-specific stuff to clrzmq will be acceptable > upstream, so they'll have to be broken apart. Yes, particularly dependency on ironpython assembly is a no-go. I am using only very bottom of clrzmq (P/Invoke), so it will be trivial to separate it. zmq devels adviced me to check out pure .net zmq provided (NetMQ). I have to find out how it fits with pyzmq. > Why can't ZeroMQ.Iron be a separate assembly? it can be a separate assembly referencing platform/architecture specific libzmq > In particular, it would be nice if that assembly > was not platform specific and could reference the various > platform-specific clrzmq DLLs. It appears that clrzmq uses different > DLLs for .NET and Mono, so choosing the right DLL to load > automatically could be interesting. It may make sense to maintain a > fork of pyzmq, but that depends on what upstream would be interested > in supporting. I am in touch with zmq folks. > > This is a common problem (I would love to do the same for SQLite and > expat) so it would be nice to have an idea of what works and what > doesn't. > > - Jeff --pawel _______________________________________________ Ironpython-users mailing list Ironpython-users@python.org https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/ironpython-users
