hi, I have noticed that the long standing string/unicode subject surfaced again in chat (#1414) For long time I was convinced that jython uses the same strategy as ironpython in regards to str/unicode aliasing. There was hope to get cpython compatibility at similar level as jython (e.g. django works under jython).
Thanks to Kuno (see https://github.com/IronLanguages/main/pull/1331), I was corrected. jython made a change in 2.5, so str and unicode are distinct types. I believe this change alone made a big difference with respect to their cpython compatibility. Now the question is what stops us from doing the same? We could have a distinctive type entry for str and unicode, but keep the existing implementation which uses .net string as storage for byte strings. The arguments passed to .net will be mapped exactly as they are today. The results coming back from .net would surface as unicode (which they are). Marcus expressed concerns "shipping our own string implementation would be somehow overkill, and could severely hurt performance when interfacing with .NET. I think it's not worth the effort for 2.x" Marcus, does your concern still apply if the implementation follows the "distinctive type entry" idea? The positives I can see: - able to use things out of PyPI without tweaking - no patching of stdlib - no time spend on investigating another bug report which turns out to be str/unicode alias. I would never expect it to cause stack overflow (#1414). - chance to move forward with ironclad - the str/unicode aliasing is the biggest road block when trying to fix numpy integration The negatives I am aware of: - this has a potential to break existing ironpython code which already has a lot of handcrafted tweaks for str/unicode aliasing. This would have to be taken out. - working on this, would take resources from working on 3 I am sure, that as usually I am overlooking and/or trivializing something, so please speak up. cheers, --pawel
_______________________________________________ Ironpython-users mailing list Ironpython-users@python.org https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/ironpython-users
