[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CAMEL-24744?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Claus Ibsen updated CAMEL-24744:
--------------------------------
Description:
The compact notation is deprecated (CAMEL-24722 rewrote the hints, CAMEL-24723
reports it in {{camel validate yaml --canonical}} and warns at runtime), but
what camel-jbang itself generates is still written in it, so a user or an AI
agent starting from a Camel-generated file starts from the deprecated form and
{{camel run}} warns on the first run:
* the MCP scaffold tools: {{AiPipelineScaffoldTools}} ({{- simple: "${body}
contains 'invoice'"}} in a when) and {{OpenApiTools}} ({{constant: "TODO:
implement ..."}})
* the {{camel init}} templates {{yaml.ftl}} (what {{camel init foo.yaml}}
writes), {{integration.yaml.ftl}}, {{kamelet-source.yaml.ftl}},
{{kamelet-action.yaml.ftl}} ({{setBody: {simple: ...}}}, {{- log: "..."}})
* the bundled examples under {{camel-jbang-core/src/main/resources/examples}}
(tui-hello-world, message-size, orders)
Write them in the canonical format ({{expression: {simple: {expression:
"..."}}}}, {{log: {message: "..."}}}) and guard them: the templates and
examples through {{camel validate yaml --canonical}} in a test, the scaffold
tools through their existing tests asserting the canonical form.
Noted on CAMEL-24722.
was:
The compact notation is deprecated (CAMEL-24722 rewrote the hints, CAMEL-24723
reports it in {{camel validate yaml --canonical}} and warns at runtime), but
what camel-jbang itself generates is still written in it, so a user or an AI
agent starting from a Camel-generated file starts from the deprecated form and
{{camel run}} warns on the first run:
* the MCP scaffold tools: {{AiPipelineScaffoldTools}} ({{- simple: "${body}
contains 'invoice'"}} in a when) and {{OpenApiTools}} ({{constant: "TODO:
implement ..."}})
* the {{camel init}} templates {{integration.yaml.ftl}},
{{kamelet-source.yaml.ftl}}, {{kamelet-action.yaml.ftl}} ({{setBody: {simple:
...}}}, {{- log: "..."}})
* the bundled examples under {{camel-jbang-core/src/main/resources/examples}}
(tui-hello-world, message-size, orders)
Write them in the canonical format ({{expression: {simple: {expression:
"..."}}}}, {{log: {message: "..."}}}) and guard them: the templates and
examples through {{camel validate yaml --canonical}} in a test, the scaffold
tools through their existing tests asserting the canonical form.
Noted on CAMEL-24722.
> camel-jbang - the YAML the MCP scaffold tools, the camel init templates and
> the bundled examples generate is in the deprecated compact notation; write it
> in the canonical format
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: CAMEL-24744
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CAMEL-24744
> Project: Camel
> Issue Type: Improvement
> Components: camel-jbang
> Reporter: Claus Ibsen
> Assignee: Claus Ibsen
> Priority: Major
>
> The compact notation is deprecated (CAMEL-24722 rewrote the hints,
> CAMEL-24723 reports it in {{camel validate yaml --canonical}} and warns at
> runtime), but what camel-jbang itself generates is still written in it, so a
> user or an AI agent starting from a Camel-generated file starts from the
> deprecated form and {{camel run}} warns on the first run:
> * the MCP scaffold tools: {{AiPipelineScaffoldTools}} ({{- simple: "${body}
> contains 'invoice'"}} in a when) and {{OpenApiTools}} ({{constant: "TODO:
> implement ..."}})
> * the {{camel init}} templates {{yaml.ftl}} (what {{camel init foo.yaml}}
> writes), {{integration.yaml.ftl}}, {{kamelet-source.yaml.ftl}},
> {{kamelet-action.yaml.ftl}} ({{setBody: {simple: ...}}}, {{- log: "..."}})
> * the bundled examples under {{camel-jbang-core/src/main/resources/examples}}
> (tui-hello-world, message-size, orders)
> Write them in the canonical format ({{expression: {simple: {expression:
> "..."}}}}, {{log: {message: "..."}}}) and guard them: the templates and
> examples through {{camel validate yaml --canonical}} in a test, the scaffold
> tools through their existing tests asserting the canonical form.
> Noted on CAMEL-24722.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)
