Claus Ibsen created CAMEL-26927:
-----------------------------------

             Summary: camel-wordpress - each endpoint should use its own site 
URL and credentials
                 Key: CAMEL-26927
                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CAMEL-26927
             Project: Camel
          Issue Type: Bug
          Components: camel-wordpress
            Reporter: Claus Ibsen
            Assignee: Claus Ibsen
             Fix For: 4.24.0, 4.22.3, 4.18.6


The WordPress client of camel-wordpress is held in one static 
{{WordpressServiceProvider}} for the whole application instead of on the 
endpoint. With more than one wordpress endpoint in the same application, all of 
them end up sharing the settings of one endpoint.

h3. Today

* {{WordpressEndpoint.configureProperties(...)}} calls 
{{WordpressServiceProvider.getInstance().init(apiConfiguration)}}, which 
replaces the services of the static singleton with ones built from this 
endpoint's {{url}}, {{apiVersion}}, {{user}} and {{password}}.
* The producers ({{AbstractWordpressProducer}}, {{WordpressPostProducer}}, 
{{WordpressUserProducer}}) and consumers ({{WordpressPostConsumer}}, 
{{WordpressUserConsumer}}) read their services and {{hasAuthentication()}} from 
that singleton in their constructors, which run after all endpoints of the 
routes are configured.
* So every wordpress producer and consumer uses the site {{url}}, {{user}} and 
{{password}} of the endpoint that was configured last. For example, a consumer 
without {{user}}/{{password}} next to a producer with them (the example in the 
component docs) polls with the producer's credentials, or the producer is 
rejected for missing credentials, depending on which endpoint was configured 
last. Two endpoints for two sites both talk to one site.

h3. After the change

Each endpoint owns its own {{WordpressServiceProvider}}:
* {{WordpressServiceProvider}} gets a public way to build a provider for one 
{{WordpressAPIConfiguration}} (for example a static 
{{create(WordpressAPIConfiguration)}} factory), with final fields.
* {{WordpressEndpoint}} builds its provider in {{doInit()}} (or lazily, so 
endpoints configured with setters also work), holds it in a field, and exposes 
{{getService(Class)}} and {{hasAuthentication()}}. It no longer calls 
{{WordpressServiceProvider.getInstance().init(...)}}.
* Producers and consumers take their services and {{hasAuthentication()}} from 
{{getEndpoint()}}, preferably in {{doStart()}}, instead of from 
{{WordpressServiceProvider.getInstance()}}.
* {{getInstance()}} and {{init(...)}} stay for API compatibility (the service 
adapter tests and possibly user code use them); on main they are marked 
{{@Deprecated}}.
* No cache of providers keyed on {{WordpressAPIConfiguration.equals}}.

h3. Tests

* {{WordpressEndpointsUseTheirOwnSiteTest}}: two endpoints pointing at two 
local mock servers (free ports via {{AvailablePortFinder}}, not the fixed 9009 
server of {{WordpressMockServerTestSupport}}) with different users. A producer 
of each endpoint creates a post; assert that each server received only its own 
endpoint's request with its own {{Authorization}} header. Run both orders of 
endpoint creation.
* Consumer variant: polling each endpoint reads only from its own server.
* An endpoint without {{user}} sends no {{Authorization}} header, also when an 
endpoint with {{user}}/{{password}} is created after it.
* The existing {{WordpressComponentTest}}, {{WordpressPostOperationTest}}, 
{{WordpressUserOperationTest}}, {{WordpressAPIConfigurationTest}} and the 
service adapter tests keep passing.

h3. Upgrade guide

A note in the upgrade guides (4.24, and the 4.22.3 and 4.18.6 sections, all on 
main): camel-wordpress endpoints no longer initialise 
{{WordpressServiceProvider.getInstance()}}; each endpoint uses its own client. 
Code that read services from the singleton after creating an endpoint must call 
{{init(...)}} itself.

No endpoint options are added or removed.



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v10.3.26#10030026)

Reply via email to