Claus Ibsen created CAMEL-26929:
-----------------------------------

             Summary: camel-jbang - camel get, cmd and stop: get consumer and 
get producer fail, an exact name also matches longer names, and cmd send 
without a name sends nothing
                 Key: CAMEL-26929
                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CAMEL-26929
             Project: Camel
          Issue Type: Bug
          Components: camel-jbang
            Reporter: Claus Ibsen
             Fix For: 4.24.0


Found by a scan of the Camel CLI on 2026-11-13, with the unpacked 
4.24.0-SNAPSHOT camel-launcher on macOS (JDK 25). *(exp)* means reproduced by 
experiment, *(read)* means traced in the code. Paths are relative to 
{{dsl/camel-jbang/}}, and line numbers are from main at that time. Earlier 
findings of this kind: CAMEL-26901, CAMEL-26911 to CAMEL-26914.

h3. 1. camel get consumer and camel get producer fail with exit 70 on any 
integration with a consumer (exp, high)

{{ListConsumer.java:105}} and {{ListProducer.java:100}} (camel-jbang-core 
{{commands/process}}) read the key {{class}}, but since CAMEL-24565 (released 
in 4.23.0) the consoles are records and the key is {{clazz}} 
({{ConsumerDevConsole.java:66}}, {{ProducerDevConsole.java:40}}). {{getType}} 
then calls {{endsWith}} on null:

{noformat}
$ camel get consumer --json
{"status":"error","code":70,"message":"Cannot invoke 
\"String.endsWith(String)\" because \"s\" is null"}
{noformat}

{{ListConsumer:106}} also reads {{hostedService}}, while the key is {{hosted}}. 
The TUI was fixed ({{StatusParser.java:473,555}}), the CLI was not. The tests 
pass because {{ListConsumerTest:129}} writes the old key by hand: build the 
fixtures from the console records so a renamed key breaks a test.

h3. 2. An exact name also matches longer names, and camel stop stops them all 
(exp, high)

{{ProcessFinder.pattern()}} (lines 247-254) treats a name as a prefix unless it 
ends with {{!}}. With {{orders}} and {{orders-v2}} running, every 
single-integration command for {{orders}} fails with exit 3, and {{camel stop 
orders}} stops both (also logger, reset-stats, stop-route, trace). The error 
message does not mention {{orders!}}. When exactly one name equals the given 
name, take it.

h3. 3. camel cmd send without a name sends nothing and reports success (exp, 
high)

Without a name {{CamelSendAction}} (lines 209-214) starts an empty local Camel. 
With no {{--endpoint}} it prints {{Sent (success)}} and exits 0 
({{SendDevConsole.findTarget}} returns null, lines 157-159 and 288-294). 
{{camel-jbang-tips.adoc:89}} recommends exactly this command for {{--stub}}. 
With {{--endpoint=direct:x --reply}} it waits 30 s (33.7 s measured) against 
the CLI's own empty Camel and exits 124. A missing target should be an error, 
and an internal endpoint ({{direct:}}, {{seda:}}, {{stub:}}) without a name 
should use the one running integration or list them. Without a name, receive, 
send and the chaos commands also pick their target by three different rules.

h3. 4. Options that are silently ignored (exp)

* {{cmd route-structure --json}} ignores {{--filter}}, {{--sort}}, {{--brief}} 
and {{--description}}, and exits 0 for a filter that matches nothing 
({{CamelRouteStructureAction.java:136,154-157}}); the text output and 
route-dump handle them.
* {{cmd logger --logging-level=BOGUS}} sets the logger to ERROR and exits 0 
({{LoggerAction.java:85-91}}); without a name it does it to every integration.
* {{cmd send --timeout}} only bounds how long the CLI waits, not the send 
({{SendDevConsole.java:144-146,270-281}}): {{direct:nope}} ends in a CLI 
timeout (exit 124) instead of "No consumers available". A timeout below 5000 is 
raised to 5000 without a word.
* {{cmd receive --since}} never filters: the message timestamp is 0 for most 
components ({{ReceiveDevConsole.java:294-296}}); fall back to the exchange 
creation time. {{--action=status --output=json}} prints the table, the JSON 
stream starts with "Starting to receive..." on stdout, {{--action=stop}} prints 
"Starting to receive...", and a start with an endpoint that matches nothing 
exits 0.
* {{cmd browse --endpoint=seda:foo}}, the example in its own help, never 
matches; only {{seda://foo}} does ({{BrowseDevConsole.java:123,176}}).

h3. 5. JSON and output (exp)

* {{uptime}} is a start timestamp in most commands but a duration in 
{{CamelRouteStatus.java:147-148}} and {{CamelRouteGroupStatus.java:119-120}}, 
so {{--sort=age}} sorts the opposite way in {{get route}}.
* {{pid}} is a string in trace status, browse, stub, logger and get about, and 
a number elsewhere; {{name}} is the file name in the action commands and the 
short name in the listings.
* {{get error}}, {{get history}} and {{top source}} JSON rows have no pid or 
name; {{get about --json}} is an object for one integration and an array for 
several.
* ANSI escape codes in piped output of {{cmd send --reply}}, {{trace 
--action=dump}} and {{cmd browse --dump}} ({{MessageTableHelper}}, 
{{--logging-color}} defaults to true). #29826 fixes {{camel log}} only.
* {{cmd send}} and the trace dump have no {{--json}}.

h3. 6. The trace file grows without limit (exp)

{{<pid>-trace.json}} grows while tracing is on 
({{FileCliConnectorTransport.java:398-417}}): 758 KB after 10 minutes of a 2 s 
timer, about 15 MB a minute at 100 exchanges/s. 
{{CamelTraceAction.tailTraceFiles}} reads the whole file for every {{--tail}}. 
Cap or rotate it, and read the tail from the end.

h3. 7. Smaller

* {{get transformer}} warns with an NPE for every integration without 
transformers ({{ListTransformer.java:70-71}}); 
{{ProcessBaseCommand.forEachIntegration}} turns CLI bugs like this into 
warnings.
* With nothing running, single-integration commands say "No running Camel 
integration matches: *" and exit 3; an ambiguous name is exit 3 here and exit 2 
for chaos.
* {{cmd send}} to an integration with several routes and no {{--endpoint}} 
takes the first route, which may be a timer.
* {{camel stop}} with no name stops every integration without asking when there 
is no terminal. During the scan one agent's bare stop stopped the integrations 
of other agents. Consider requiring {{*}} or {{--all}} when more than one runs.
* Bare {{camel get}} and {{camel top}} have no {{--json}}; {{camel ps}} has no 
name filter.

h3. Came out clean

CAMEL-26911 items 3 and 4 (trace/receive clear, torn replies) are fixed on 
main. Not-found handling (exit 3 plus a JSON error), {{--sort}} validation, 
{{--watch}} without a terminal, route control, {{cmd load}}, {{gc}} and {{camel 
restart}} work, and every option in the 75 documented example lines exists.

_Claude Code on behalf of Claus Ibsen_



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v10.3.26#10030026)

Reply via email to