[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CAMEL-10694?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
 ]

Baltej Singh updated CAMEL-10694:
---------------------------------
    Description: 
The simple example that shows the issues with various {{}}, 
=$simple{file:onlyname} and ${bean:...} combinations


------------fileNaming.properties ------------ trace=false in.path=c:/temp/in
in.path0=c:/temp/test/in0
in.path1=c:/temp/test/in1
in.path2=c:/temp/test/in2
in.path3=c:/temp/test/in3
archive.path=c:/temp/test/archive/
common.fname.pattern=$simple{file:onlyname}
datetime.fname.pattern=$simple{date:now:yyyy-MM-dd_hh-mm-ss.SSS}-$simple{file:onlyname}
incounter.datetime.fname.pattern=${bean:inboundCounter.incrementAndGet}-$simple{date:now:yyyy-MM-dd_hh-mm-ss.SSS}

----------End fileNaming.properties ------------


{noformat}

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<beans xmlns="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans";
        xmlns:camel="http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring"; 
xmlns:p="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans";
        xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance";
        xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans 
http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans/spring-beans-3.0.xsd        
http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring 
http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring/camel-spring.xsd";>


        <bean 
class="org.apache.camel.spring.spi.BridgePropertyPlaceholderConfigurer"
                id="bridgePropertyPlaceholder">
                <p:property name="location" 
value="classpath:fileNaming.properties" />
        </bean>
        
        <bean class="java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicLong" 
id="inboundCounter" />
          
        <camelContext id="testFileNamingContext" trace="{{trace}}"
                xmlns="http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring";>
                <route id="workingRoute">
                        <camel:description>This route produces: 
C:\temp\test\in\done\0-workingRoute-testNaming.xml</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:c:/temp/test/in?moveFailed=.failed/$simple{file:onlyname}&amp;move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-workingRoute-$simple{file:onlyname}"
 />
                        <log message="workingRoute" />
                        <to id="_toW" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>

                <route id="errorRoute0">
                        <camel:description>Using {{common.fname.pattern}} 
causes inboundCounter bean reference to fail.   This route produces: 
C:\temp\test\in0\done\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute0-testNaming.xml 
</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:c:/temp/test/in0?move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute0-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute0" />
                        <to id="_to0" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>
                
                <route id="errorRoute1">
                        <camel:description>Using {{in.path1}} and 
{{archive.path}} causes inboundCounter bean reference to fail. This route 
produces:  
C:\temp\test\archive\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute1-testNaming.xml 
</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:{{in.path1}}?move={{archive.path}}/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute1-$simple{file:onlyname}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute1" />
                        <to id="_to1" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>

                <route id="errorRoute2">
                        <camel:description>This route produces:  
C:\temp\test\in2\done\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute2-testNaming.xml</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:{{in.path2}}?move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute2-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute2" />
                        <to id="_to2" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>


                <route id="errorRoute3">
                        <camel:description>This route produces: 
C:\temp\test\archive\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute3-testNaming.xml 
</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:{{in.path3}}?move={{archive.path}}/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute3-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute3" />
                        <to id="_to3" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>
        </camelContext>
</beans>

{noformat}


------------

Note that NO errors are thrown in console

-------------
[pache.camel.spring.Main.main()] SpringCamelContext             INFO  Total 5 
routes, of which 5 are started.
[pache.camel.spring.Main.main()] SpringCamelContext             INFO  Apache 
Camel 2.18.1 (CamelContext: testFileNamingContext) started in 2.402 seconds
[d #3 - file://c:/temp/test/in0] errorRoute0                    INFO  
errorRoute0
[d #4 - file://c:/temp/test/in1] errorRoute1                    INFO  
errorRoute1
[d #5 - file://c:/temp/test/in2] errorRoute2                    INFO  
errorRoute2
[d #6 - file://c:/temp/test/in3] errorRoute3                    INFO  
errorRoute3
[d #6 - file://c:/temp/test/in3] errorRoute3                    INFO  
errorRoute3



=====================
C:\temp\test>tree
Folder PATH listing for volume RAW7121218
Volume serial number is 0C09-AE01
C:.
├───archive
├───in
│   └───done
├───in0
│   └───done
├───in1
├───in2
│   └───done
└───in3

C:\temp\test>ls -1R
.:
archive
in
in0
in1
in2
in3

./archive:
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute1-testNaming.xml
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute3-testNaming.xml

./in:
done

./in/done:
0-workingRoute-testNaming.xml

./in0:
done

./in0/done:
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute0-testNaming.xml

./in1:

./in2:
done

./in2/done:
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute2-testNaming.xml

./in3:


  was:
The simple example that shows the issues with various {{}}, 
=$simple{file:onlyname} and ${bean:...} combinations


------------fileNaming.properties ------------ trace=false in.path=c:/temp/in
in.path0=c:/temp/test/in0
in.path1=c:/temp/test/in1
in.path2=c:/temp/test/in2
in.path3=c:/temp/test/in3
archive.path=c:/temp/test/archive/
common.fname.pattern=$simple{file:onlyname}
datetime.fname.pattern=$simple{date:now:yyyy-MM-dd_hh-mm-ss.SSS}-$simple{file:onlyname}
incounter.datetime.fname.pattern=${bean:inboundCounter.incrementAndGet}-$simple{date:now:yyyy-MM-dd_hh-mm-ss.SSS}

----------End fileNaming.properties ------------




<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<beans xmlns="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans";
        xmlns:camel="http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring"; 
xmlns:p="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans";
        xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance";
        xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans 
http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans/spring-beans-3.0.xsd        
http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring 
http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring/camel-spring.xsd";>


        <bean 
class="org.apache.camel.spring.spi.BridgePropertyPlaceholderConfigurer"
                id="bridgePropertyPlaceholder">
                <p:property name="location" 
value="classpath:fileNaming.properties" />
        </bean>
        
        <bean class="java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicLong" 
id="inboundCounter" />
          
        <camelContext id="testFileNamingContext" trace="{{trace}}"
                xmlns="http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring";>
                <route id="workingRoute">
                        <camel:description>This route produces: 
C:\temp\test\in\done\0-workingRoute-testNaming.xml</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:c:/temp/test/in?moveFailed=.failed/$simple{file:onlyname}&amp;move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-workingRoute-$simple{file:onlyname}"
 />
                        <log message="workingRoute" />
                        <to id="_toW" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>

                <route id="errorRoute0">
                        <camel:description>Using {{common.fname.pattern}} 
causes inboundCounter bean reference to fail.   This route produces: 
C:\temp\test\in0\done\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute0-testNaming.xml 
</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:c:/temp/test/in0?move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute0-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute0" />
                        <to id="_to0" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>
                
                <route id="errorRoute1">
                        <camel:description>Using {{in.path1}} and 
{{archive.path}} causes inboundCounter bean reference to fail. This route 
produces:  
C:\temp\test\archive\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute1-testNaming.xml 
</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:{{in.path1}}?move={{archive.path}}/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute1-$simple{file:onlyname}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute1" />
                        <to id="_to1" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>

                <route id="errorRoute2">
                        <camel:description>This route produces:  
C:\temp\test\in2\done\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute2-testNaming.xml</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:{{in.path2}}?move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute2-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute2" />
                        <to id="_to2" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>


                <route id="errorRoute3">
                        <camel:description>This route produces: 
C:\temp\test\archive\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute3-testNaming.xml 
</camel:description>
                        <from
                                
uri="file:{{in.path3}}?move={{archive.path}}/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute3-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
 />
                        <log message="errorRoute3" />
                        <to id="_to3" uri="mock://complete" />
                </route>
        </camelContext>
</beans>



------------

Note that NO errors are thrown in console

-------------
[pache.camel.spring.Main.main()] SpringCamelContext             INFO  Total 5 
routes, of which 5 are started.
[pache.camel.spring.Main.main()] SpringCamelContext             INFO  Apache 
Camel 2.18.1 (CamelContext: testFileNamingContext) started in 2.402 seconds
[d #3 - file://c:/temp/test/in0] errorRoute0                    INFO  
errorRoute0
[d #4 - file://c:/temp/test/in1] errorRoute1                    INFO  
errorRoute1
[d #5 - file://c:/temp/test/in2] errorRoute2                    INFO  
errorRoute2
[d #6 - file://c:/temp/test/in3] errorRoute3                    INFO  
errorRoute3
[d #6 - file://c:/temp/test/in3] errorRoute3                    INFO  
errorRoute3



=====================
C:\temp\test>tree
Folder PATH listing for volume RAW7121218
Volume serial number is 0C09-AE01
C:.
├───archive
├───in
│   └───done
├───in0
│   └───done
├───in1
├───in2
│   └───done
└───in3

C:\temp\test>ls -1R
.:
archive
in
in0
in1
in2
in3

./archive:
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute1-testNaming.xml
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute3-testNaming.xml

./in:
done

./in/done:
0-workingRoute-testNaming.xml

./in0:
done

./in0/done:
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute0-testNaming.xml

./in1:

./in2:
done

./in2/done:
inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute2-testNaming.xml

./in3:



> Some combinations of {{}} properties refernce, bean and simple language fail
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: CAMEL-10694
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CAMEL-10694
>             Project: Camel
>          Issue Type: Bug
>          Components: camel-core, camel-spring
>    Affects Versions: 2.18.1
>         Environment: Windows
>            Reporter: Baltej Singh
>         Attachments: fileNaming.properties, testNaming.xml
>
>
> The simple example that shows the issues with various {{}}, 
> =$simple{file:onlyname} and ${bean:...} combinations
> ------------fileNaming.properties ------------ trace=false in.path=c:/temp/in
> in.path0=c:/temp/test/in0
> in.path1=c:/temp/test/in1
> in.path2=c:/temp/test/in2
> in.path3=c:/temp/test/in3
> archive.path=c:/temp/test/archive/
> common.fname.pattern=$simple{file:onlyname}
> datetime.fname.pattern=$simple{date:now:yyyy-MM-dd_hh-mm-ss.SSS}-$simple{file:onlyname}
> incounter.datetime.fname.pattern=${bean:inboundCounter.incrementAndGet}-$simple{date:now:yyyy-MM-dd_hh-mm-ss.SSS}
> ----------End fileNaming.properties ------------
> {noformat}
> <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
> <beans xmlns="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans";
>       xmlns:camel="http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring"; 
> xmlns:p="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans";
>       xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance";
>       xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans 
> http://www.springframework.org/schema/beans/spring-beans-3.0.xsd        
> http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring 
> http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring/camel-spring.xsd";>
>       <bean 
> class="org.apache.camel.spring.spi.BridgePropertyPlaceholderConfigurer"
>               id="bridgePropertyPlaceholder">
>               <p:property name="location" 
> value="classpath:fileNaming.properties" />
>       </bean>
>       
>       <bean class="java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicLong" 
> id="inboundCounter" />
>         
>       <camelContext id="testFileNamingContext" trace="{{trace}}"
>               xmlns="http://camel.apache.org/schema/spring";>
>               <route id="workingRoute">
>                       <camel:description>This route produces: 
> C:\temp\test\in\done\0-workingRoute-testNaming.xml</camel:description>
>                       <from
>                               
> uri="file:c:/temp/test/in?moveFailed=.failed/$simple{file:onlyname}&amp;move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-workingRoute-$simple{file:onlyname}"
>  />
>                       <log message="workingRoute" />
>                       <to id="_toW" uri="mock://complete" />
>               </route>
>               <route id="errorRoute0">
>                       <camel:description>Using {{common.fname.pattern}} 
> causes inboundCounter bean reference to fail.   This route produces: 
> C:\temp\test\in0\done\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute0-testNaming.xml
>  </camel:description>
>                       <from
>                               
> uri="file:c:/temp/test/in0?move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute0-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
>  />
>                       <log message="errorRoute0" />
>                       <to id="_to0" uri="mock://complete" />
>               </route>
>               
>               <route id="errorRoute1">
>                       <camel:description>Using {{in.path1}} and 
> {{archive.path}} causes inboundCounter bean reference to fail. This route 
> produces:  
> C:\temp\test\archive\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute1-testNaming.xml
>  </camel:description>
>                       <from
>                               
> uri="file:{{in.path1}}?move={{archive.path}}/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute1-$simple{file:onlyname}"
>  />
>                       <log message="errorRoute1" />
>                       <to id="_to1" uri="mock://complete" />
>               </route>
>               <route id="errorRoute2">
>                       <camel:description>This route produces:  
> C:\temp\test\in2\done\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute2-testNaming.xml</camel:description>
>                       <from
>                               
> uri="file:{{in.path2}}?move=done/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute2-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
>  />
>                       <log message="errorRoute2" />
>                       <to id="_to2" uri="mock://complete" />
>               </route>
>               <route id="errorRoute3">
>                       <camel:description>This route produces: 
> C:\temp\test\archive\inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute3-testNaming.xml
>  </camel:description>
>                       <from
>                               
> uri="file:{{in.path3}}?move={{archive.path}}/${bean:inboundCounter.getAndIncrement}-errorRoute3-{{common.fname.pattern}}"
>  />
>                       <log message="errorRoute3" />
>                       <to id="_to3" uri="mock://complete" />
>               </route>
>       </camelContext>
> </beans>
> {noformat}
> ------------
> Note that NO errors are thrown in console
> -------------
> [pache.camel.spring.Main.main()] SpringCamelContext             INFO  Total 5 
> routes, of which 5 are started.
> [pache.camel.spring.Main.main()] SpringCamelContext             INFO  Apache 
> Camel 2.18.1 (CamelContext: testFileNamingContext) started in 2.402 seconds
> [d #3 - file://c:/temp/test/in0] errorRoute0                    INFO  
> errorRoute0
> [d #4 - file://c:/temp/test/in1] errorRoute1                    INFO  
> errorRoute1
> [d #5 - file://c:/temp/test/in2] errorRoute2                    INFO  
> errorRoute2
> [d #6 - file://c:/temp/test/in3] errorRoute3                    INFO  
> errorRoute3
> [d #6 - file://c:/temp/test/in3] errorRoute3                    INFO  
> errorRoute3
> =====================
> C:\temp\test>tree
> Folder PATH listing for volume RAW7121218
> Volume serial number is 0C09-AE01
> C:.
> ├───archive
> ├───in
> │   └───done
> ├───in0
> │   └───done
> ├───in1
> ├───in2
> │   └───done
> └───in3
> C:\temp\test>ls -1R
> .:
> archive
> in
> in0
> in1
> in2
> in3
> ./archive:
> inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute1-testNaming.xml
> inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute3-testNaming.xml
> ./in:
> done
> ./in/done:
> 0-workingRoute-testNaming.xml
> ./in0:
> done
> ./in0/done:
> inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute0-testNaming.xml
> ./in1:
> ./in2:
> done
> ./in2/done:
> inboundCounter.getAndIncrement-errorRoute2-testNaming.xml
> ./in3:



--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)

Reply via email to