[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-9376?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=15733112#comment-15733112
]
ASF subversion and git services commented on CLOUDSTACK-9376:
-------------------------------------------------------------
Commit 8769597523a488da0b4b989c5659b47c664df8ee in cloudstack's branch
refs/heads/master from [[email protected]]
[ https://git-wip-us.apache.org/repos/asf?p=cloudstack.git;h=8769597 ]
Merge pull request #1763 from sudhansu7/CLOUDSTACK-9594
CLOUDSTACK-9594: API "list templates templatefilter=all" reveals allAPI "list
templates templatefilter=all" reveals all templates.
Using a "list templates templatefilter=all" API call any domain admin can see
all templates of all domains in ACS. Information returned includes the account
and domain of the template's owner.
The template data shows what that VM is using and any hints from the label.
This would give an advantage in what attack vectors to use. The account and
domain can possibly be used in brute force attack to guess the password and
login information.
Test Scenario:
created two accounts in different domain.
```
mysql> select account_id,username,api_key from user where id in (4,5);
+------------+-----------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| account_id | username | api_key
|
+------------+-----------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| 4 | sudadmin1 |
3qeSuWadNzUFZ_i6c6zbwafjM3Eo0TWpkHw3En9jNsg5Ditk2N18DnbbL2quBYQ7FsdXQ8rwxbyFlE8vyUTwEg
|
| 5 | sudadmin |
N5uHVOrg1Ek1F1a_5OXTz4WpLG3ewHqcbPUSBjQ-2CTJdxmUe2go0S8fyqH4Np0scYiehYg2KqthZXCWEyKx1A
|
+------------+-----------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
2 rows in set (0.00 sec)
mysql> select account_name,domain_id from account where id in (4,5);
+--------------+-----------+
| account_name | domain_id |
+--------------+-----------+
| sudadmin | 2 |
| sudadmin1 | 3 |
+--------------+-----------+
2 rows in set (0.00 sec)
```
User sudadmin registered a private template named 'Debian'.
http://10.147.59.107:8080/client/api?apikey=N5uHVOrg1Ek1F1a_5OXTz4WpLG3ewHqcbPUSBjQ-2CTJdxmUe2go0S8fyqH4Np0scYiehYg2KqthZXCWEyKx1A&command=listTemplates&templatefilter=self&signature=ODt7zEWCLL20z1FT%2FIkd1molRaM%3D
listTemplate with "templatefilter=self", lists the newly registered template.
```
<listtemplatesresponse cloud-stack-version="4.8.0">
<count>1</count>
<template>
<id>51026d32-60ee-4e25-8ffd-3fa3c57fc14c</id>
<name>Debian</name>
<displaytext>Debian</displaytext>
<ispublic>false</ispublic>
<created>2016-11-10T17:18:00-0500</created>
<isready>true</isready>
<passwordenabled>false</passwordenabled>
<format>VHD</format>
<isfeatured>false</isfeatured>
<crossZones>false</crossZones>
<ostypeid>38c1fc84-a687-11e6-a8c8-06f654000053</ostypeid>
<ostypename>Debian GNU/Linux 7(64-bit)</ostypename>
<account>sudadmin</account>
<zoneid>25fa5b74-d4c2-4bad-8e3a-ceffcd10985e</zoneid>
<zonename>z1</zonename>
<status>Download Complete</status>
<size>2621440000</size>
<templatetype>USER</templatetype>
<hypervisor>XenServer</hypervisor>
<domain>SUDDOMAIN</domain>
<domainid>a350c00d-4048-4876-ae09-74ad4b7bb28c</domainid>
<isextractable>false</isextractable>
<checksum>e87a6d7291b999c92baa9623c9c3c207</checksum>
<details>{hypervisortoolsversion=xenserver61}</details>
<sshkeyenabled>false</sshkeyenabled>
<isdynamicallyscalable>false</isdynamicallyscalable>
</template>
</listtemplatesresponse>
```
User: sudadmin1
listTemplate with "templatefilter=self" does not list any template.
http://10.147.59.107:8080/client/api?apikey=3qeSuWadNzUFZ_i6c6zbwafjM3Eo0TWpkHw3En9jNsg5Ditk2N18DnbbL2quBYQ7FsdXQ8rwxbyFlE8vyUTwEg&command=listTemplates&templatefilter=self&signature=RfKsdg3RxDkqJotbTlHU2RdbdPA%3D
`<listtemplatesresponse cloud-stack-version="4.8.0"/>
`
NO TEMPLATES
**listTemplate with "templatefilter=all" lists all templates**
http://10.147.59.107:8080/client/api?apikey=3qeSuWadNzUFZ_i6c6zbwafjM3Eo0TWpkHw3En9jNsg5Ditk2N18DnbbL2quBYQ7FsdXQ8rwxbyFlE8vyUTwEg&command=listTemplates&templatefilter=all&signature=l5tubfyABT67d1jY702dvtZODbc%3D
Result:
```
<listtemplatesresponse cloud-stack-version="4.8.0">
<count>3</count>
<template>
<id>38451a02-a687-11e6-a8c8-06f654000053</id>
<name>CentOS 5.6(64-bit) no GUI (XenServer)</name>
<displaytext>CentOS 5.6(64-bit) no GUI (XenServer)</displaytext>
<ispublic>true</ispublic>
....
</template>
<template>
<id>51026d32-60ee-4e25-8ffd-3fa3c57fc14c</id>
<name>Debian</name>
<displaytext>Debian</displaytext>
<ispublic>false</ispublic>
<created>2016-11-10T17:18:00-0500</created>
<isready>true</isready>
<passwordenabled>false</passwordenabled>
<format>VHD</format>
<isfeatured>false</isfeatured>
<crossZones>false</crossZones>
<ostypeid>38c1fc84-a687-11e6-a8c8-06f654000053</ostypeid>
<ostypename>Debian GNU/Linux 7(64-bit)</ostypename>
**<account>sudadmin</account>**
<zoneid>25fa5b74-d4c2-4bad-8e3a-ceffcd10985e</zoneid>
<zonename>z1</zonename>
<size>2621440000</size>
<templatetype>USER</templatetype>
<hypervisor>XenServer</hypervisor>
<domain>SUDDOMAIN</domain>
<domainid>a350c00d-4048-4876-ae09-74ad4b7bb28c</domainid>
<isextractable>false</isextractable>
<checksum>e87a6d7291b999c92baa9623c9c3c207</checksum>
<details>{hypervisortoolsversion=xenserver61}</details>
<sshkeyenabled>false</sshkeyenabled>
<isdynamicallyscalable>false</isdynamicallyscalable>
</template>
<template>
<id>5f6af7bb-d965-4b9b-ab45-6d455b0d6bbe</id>
<name>SystemVM Template (XenServer)</name>
<displaytext>SystemVM Template (XenServer)</displaytext>
<ispublic>false</ispublic>
.....
</template>
</listtemplatesresponse>
```
**After Fix:**
http://10.147.59.107:8080/client/api?apikey=3qeSuWadNzUFZ_i6c6zbwafjM3Eo0TWpkHw3En9jNsg5Ditk2N18DnbbL2quBYQ7FsdXQ8rwxbyFlE8vyUTwEg&command=listTemplates&templatefilter=all&signature=l5tubfyABT67d1jY702dvtZODbc%3D
```
<listtemplatesresponse cloud-stack-version="4.8.0">
<count>1</count>
<template>
<id>38451a02-a687-11e6-a8c8-06f654000053</id>
<name>CentOS 5.6(64-bit) no GUI (XenServer)</name>
<displaytext>CentOS 5.6(64-bit) no GUI (XenServer)</displaytext>
<ispublic>true</ispublic>
<created>2016-11-10T09:32:44-0500</created>
<isready>true</isready>
<passwordenabled>false</passwordenabled>
<format>VHD</format>
<isfeatured>true</isfeatured>
<crossZones>true</crossZones>
<ostypeid>38a2bfd6-a687-11e6-a8c8-06f654000053</ostypeid>
<ostypename>CentOS 5.6 (64-bit)</ostypename>
<account>system</account>
<zoneid>25fa5b74-d4c2-4bad-8e3a-ceffcd10985e</zoneid>
<zonename>z1</zonename>
<size>21474836480</size>
<templatetype>BUILTIN</templatetype>
<hypervisor>XenServer</hypervisor>
<domain>ROOT</domain>
<domainid>383e0ea6-a687-11e6-a8c8-06f654000053</domainid>
<isextractable>true</isextractable>
<checksum>905cec879afd9c9d22ecc8036131a180</checksum>
<sshkeyenabled>false</sshkeyenabled>
<isdynamicallyscalable>true</isdynamicallyscalable>
</template>
</listtemplatesresponse>
```
Bug has been fixed considering below points
1. templatefilter=all or isofilter=all is applicable only to admin and domain
admin.
2. With templatefilter=all or isofilter=all below are the visiblity of
templates in system.
- admin should be able to see all templates/iso in system.
- domain admin should be able to see all public template and templates under
its domain tree (including sub domain).
- domain admin in a project context should be able to see all public templates
and templates registered
as project account and templates which are shared(using
updateTemplatePermission api) with project account.
Also Modified
"test/integration/component/test_escalation_listTemplateDomainAdmin.py"
This marvin test was written for this scenario but for the second account
"templatefilter=all" is not used.
* pr/1763:
CLOUDSTACK-9594: reverted changes introduced in CLOUDSTACK-9376
CLOUDSTACK-9594: API "list templates templatefilter=all" reveals all
templates of all domains
Signed-off-by: Rohit Yadav <[email protected]>
> Using the listTemplates API with the "templatefilter=all" parameter lists all
> the templates that are available with all domains in the system.
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: CLOUDSTACK-9376
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-9376
> Project: CloudStack
> Issue Type: Bug
> Security Level: Public(Anyone can view this level - this is the
> default.)
> Affects Versions: 4.5.1
> Reporter: Abhinandan Prateek
> Assignee: Abhinandan Prateek
> Fix For: 4.9.0
>
> Attachments:
> 0001-CLOUDSTACK-9376-Restrict-listTemplates-API-with-filt.patch,
> 4.7-0001-CLOUDSTACK-9376-Restrict-listTemplates-API-with-filt.patch
>
>
> The "templatefilter=all" filter is not implemented properly for domain
> administrators.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)
