[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MATH-1507?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Baljit Singh updated MATH-1507:
-------------------------------
Description:
Let's say there is a circle on a spherical surface.
* The circle center is given by S2Point(theta=-0.6981, phi=0.87266). The
radius is irrelevant.
* Let's discretize this circle into a polygon with 100 edges. Let's make the
orientation {color:#ff0000}clockwise{color}.
* Since its a clockwise circle, from symmetry, we know that the barycenter
would be around S2Point(theta=2.44346, phi=2.268928), which is just the reverse
of the normal vector at the circle center.
* Using SphericalPolygonsSet, the calculated barycenter is
S2Point(theta=2.4922, phi=0.69889).
A few things I've already tested:
* For counterclockwise, the result is correct.
* The perimeter and surface area of the polygon is correct for both
counterclockwise and clockwise.
* The SphericalPolygonsSet barycenter seems to be a function of the circle
radius. From symmetry, we know that there should be no dependence on the circle
radius.
* The theta is kind of close. However, the phi is off about pi/2.
was:
Let's say there is a circle on a spherical surface.
* The circle center is given by S2Point(theta=-0.6981, phi=0.87266). The
radius is irrelevant.
* Let's discretize this circle into a polygon with 100 edges. Let's make the
orientation {color:#ff0000}clockwise{color}.
* Since its a clockwise circle, from symmetry, we know that the barycenter
would be around S2Point(theta=2.44346, phi=2.268928), which is just the reverse
of the normal vector at the circle center.
* Using SphericalPolygonsSet, the calculated barycenter is
S2Point(theta=2.4922, phi=0.69889).
A few things I've already tested:
* For counterclockwise, the result is correct.
* The perimeter and surface area of the polygon is correct for both
counterclockwise and clockwise.
* The SphericalPolygonsSet is a function of the circle radius. From symmetry,
we know that there should be no dependence on the circle radius.
* The theta is kind of close. However, the phi is off about pi/2.
> Barycenter of a clockwise SphericalPolygonsSet is incorrect.
> ------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: MATH-1507
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MATH-1507
> Project: Commons Math
> Issue Type: Bug
> Affects Versions: 3.6.1
> Reporter: Baljit Singh
> Priority: Major
>
> Let's say there is a circle on a spherical surface.
> * The circle center is given by S2Point(theta=-0.6981, phi=0.87266). The
> radius is irrelevant.
> * Let's discretize this circle into a polygon with 100 edges. Let's make the
> orientation {color:#ff0000}clockwise{color}.
> * Since its a clockwise circle, from symmetry, we know that the barycenter
> would be around S2Point(theta=2.44346, phi=2.268928), which is just the
> reverse of the normal vector at the circle center.
> * Using SphericalPolygonsSet, the calculated barycenter is
> S2Point(theta=2.4922, phi=0.69889).
>
> A few things I've already tested:
> * For counterclockwise, the result is correct.
> * The perimeter and surface area of the polygon is correct for both
> counterclockwise and clockwise.
> * The SphericalPolygonsSet barycenter seems to be a function of the circle
> radius. From symmetry, we know that there should be no dependence on the
> circle radius.
> * The theta is kind of close. However, the phi is off about pi/2.
>
>
>
>
--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.3.4#803005)
