Github user shixiaogang commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/3359
  
    Very sorry for the delay. I was engaged at the work in the past months, 
making flink capable of the terrible data flows in Singles Day. 
    
    RocksDBInternalTimerService is among the improvements done. 
    But we adopt a very different implementation since the initial 
implementation presented here has several problems:
    * The initial implementation requires other rocksdb instances than the one 
used in RocksDBKeyedStateBackend, which makes the resource configuration very 
difficult. 
    * The snapshotting of RocksDBInternalTimerService here is very inefficient. 
Though an asynchronous and incremental implementation is available, it will 
duplicate much code in RocksDBKeyedStateBackend.
    
    We address these problem by introducing `SecondaryKeyedState`s which 
provide non-keyed access methods to the data inside a key group. Similar to 
normal keyed state, secondary keyed states are partitioned in to key groups and 
are also stored in the backends. Hence these secondary states can also benefit 
from asynchronous and incremental snapshotting in `RocksDBKeyedStateBackend`. 
    
    What do you think of the changes ? @StefanRRichter 
    
     


---

Reply via email to