[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-23593?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=17393950#comment-17393950
 ] 

Zhu Zhu commented on FLINK-23593:
---------------------------------

>> Could the larger difference between local benchmark vs. cloud be that the 
>> cloud is running with regular HDDs and we always spill to disk because 
>> SORT_SPILLING_THRESHOLD is set to 0?

Maybe yes. Because the record processing time can be shorter on SSD and the 
increased initialization time(described in *Trying to explain the Regression*) 
will be more obvious.

Another similar suspicion is that the flink-benchmark 
[patch|https://github.com/twalthr/flink-benchmarks/commit/dfe3cad86030b551daaa7c4a5951a6e4c06fc061]
 increased `RECORDS_PER_INVOCATION` from 1_500_000 to 3_000_000. This increased 
processing time may make the regression on initialization time less obvious.

> Performance regression on 15.07.2021
> ------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: FLINK-23593
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FLINK-23593
>             Project: Flink
>          Issue Type: Bug
>          Components: API / DataStream, Benchmarks
>    Affects Versions: 1.14.0
>            Reporter: Piotr Nowojski
>            Assignee: Timo Walther
>            Priority: Blocker
>             Fix For: 1.14.0
>
>
> http://codespeed.dak8s.net:8000/timeline/?ben=sortedMultiInput&env=2
> http://codespeed.dak8s.net:8000/timeline/?ben=sortedTwoInput&env=2
> {noformat}
> pnowojski@piotr-mbp: [~/flink -  ((no branch, bisect started on pr/16589))] $ 
> git ls f4afbf3e7de..eb8100f7afe
> eb8100f7afe [4 weeks ago] (pn/bad, bad, refs/bisect/bad) 
> [FLINK-22017][coordination] Allow BLOCKING result partition to be 
> individually consumable [Thesharing]
> d2005268b1e [4 weeks ago] (HEAD, pn/bisect-4, bisect-4) 
> [FLINK-22017][coordination] Get the ConsumedPartitionGroup that 
> IntermediateResultPartition and DefaultResultPartition belong to [Thesharing]
> d8b1a6fd368 [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-23372][streaming-java] Disable 
> AllVerticesInSameSlotSharingGroupByDefault in batch mode [Timo Walther]
> 4a78097d038 [3 weeks ago] (pn/bisect-3, bisect-3, 
> refs/bisect/good-4a78097d0385749daceafd8326930c8cc5f26f1a) 
> [FLINK-21928][clients][runtime] Introduce static method constructors of 
> DuplicateJobSubmissionException for better readability. [David Moravek]
> 172b9e32215 [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-21928][clients] JobManager failover should 
> succeed, when trying to resubmit already terminated job in application mode. 
> [David Moravek]
> f483008db86 [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-21928][core] Introduce 
> org.apache.flink.util.concurrent.FutureUtils#handleException method, that 
> allows future to recover from the specied exception. [David Moravek]
> d7ac08c2ac0 [3 weeks ago] (pn/bisect-2, bisect-2, 
> refs/bisect/good-d7ac08c2ac06b9ff31707f3b8f43c07817814d4f) 
> [FLINK-22843][docs-zh] Document and code are inconsistent [ZhiJie Yang]
> 16c3ea427df [3 weeks ago] [hotfix] Split the final checkpoint related tests 
> to a separate test class. [Yun Gao]
> 31b3d37a22c [7 weeks ago] [FLINK-21089][runtime] Skip the execution of new 
> sources if finished on restore [Yun Gao]
> 20fe062e1b5 [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-21089][runtime] Skip execution for the 
> legacy source task if finished on restore [Yun Gao]
> 874c627114b [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-21089][runtime] Skip the lifecycle method of 
> operators if finished on restore [Yun Gao]
> ceaf24b1d88 [3 weeks ago] (pn/bisect-1, bisect-1, 
> refs/bisect/good-ceaf24b1d881c2345a43f305d40435519a09cec9) [hotfix] Fix 
> isClosed() for operator wrapper and proxy operator close to the operator 
> chain [Yun Gao]
> 41ea591a6db [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-22627][runtime] Remove unused slot request 
> protocol [Yangze Guo]
> 489346b60f8 [3 months ago] [FLINK-22627][runtime] Remove PendingSlotRequest 
> [Yangze Guo]
> 8ffb4d2af36 [3 months ago] [FLINK-22627][runtime] Remove TaskManagerSlot 
> [Yangze Guo]
> 72073741588 [3 months ago] [FLINK-22627][runtime] Remove SlotManagerImpl and 
> its related tests [Yangze Guo]
> bdb3b7541b3 [3 months ago] [hotfix][yarn] Remove unused internal options in 
> YarnConfigOptionsInternal [Yangze Guo]
> a6a9b192eac [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-23201][streaming] Reset alignment only for 
> the currently processed checkpoint [Anton Kalashnikov]
> b35701a35c7 [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-23201][streaming] Calculate checkpoint 
> alignment time only for last started checkpoint [Anton Kalashnikov]
> 3abec22c536 [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-23107][table-runtime] Separate 
> implementation of deduplicate rank from other rank functions [Shuo Cheng]
> 1a195f5cc59 [3 weeks ago] [FLINK-16093][docs-zh] Translate "System Functions" 
> page of "Functions" into Chinese (#16348) [ZhiJie Yang]
> {noformat}



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.3.4#803005)

Reply via email to