[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GEODE-751?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Alberto Bustamante Reyes updated GEODE-751:
-------------------------------------------
Description:
We have the following in the javadoc for method {{getEntrySize}} on interface
{{RegionMXBean}}:
{quote}
Returns the aggregate entry size (in bytes) of all entries. This will provide a
correct value only if the eviction algorithm has been set to
{{EvictionAlgorithm.LRU_MEMORY}}. For all partition regions it will show entry
size in bytes. It will also include size of all the secondary entries in the
data store. So while referring to size one should take redundancy into account.
{quote}
The region memory consumption and the eviction algorithm are two separate
concepts, we should not obligate customers to use a custom eviction algorithm
to report the correct memory consumption for a region.
We rely on this attribute to show information on PULSE, so neither the member
memory usage nor cluster memory usage are accurate if the eviction algorithm is
not configured as {{EvictionAlgorithm.LRU_MEMORY}}.
To reproduce, start up a cluster with a simple replicated region and insert
some data. You can check afterwards (from JConsole) that the attribute
"EntrySize" for the replicated region is set as "-1".
was:
We have the following in the javadoc for method {{getEntrySize}} on interface
{{RegionMXBean}}:
{quote}
Returns the aggregate entry size (in bytes) of all entries. This will provide a
correct value only if the eviction algorithm has been set to
{{EvictionAlgorithm.LRU_MEMORY}}. For all partition regions it will show entry
size in bytes. It will also include size of all the secondary entries in the
data store. So while referring to size one should take redundancy into account.
{quote}
The region memory consumption and the eviction algorithm are two separate
concepts, we should not obligate customers to use a custom eviction algorithm
to report the correct memory consumption for a region.
We rely on this attribute to show information on PULSE, so neither the member
memory usage nor cluster memory usage are accurate if the eviction algorithm is
not configured as {{EvictionAlgorithm.LRU_MEMORY}}.
To reproduce, start up a cluster with a simple replicated region and insert
some data. You can check afterwards (from JConsole) that the attribute
"EntrySize" for the replicated region is set as "-1".
We rely on this attribute to show information on PULSE, so neither the member
memory usage nor cluster memory usage are accurate if the eviction algorithm is
not configured as {{EvictionAlgorithm.LRU_MEMORY}}.
> RegionMXBean shouldn't rely on Eviction Algorithm for getEntrySize
> ------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: GEODE-751
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/GEODE-751
> Project: Geode
> Issue Type: Improvement
> Components: jmx, statistics
> Affects Versions: 1.0.0-incubating
> Reporter: Jens Deppe
> Priority: Major
>
> We have the following in the javadoc for method {{getEntrySize}} on interface
> {{RegionMXBean}}:
> {quote}
> Returns the aggregate entry size (in bytes) of all entries. This will provide
> a correct value only if the eviction algorithm has been set to
> {{EvictionAlgorithm.LRU_MEMORY}}. For all partition regions it will show
> entry size in bytes. It will also include size of all the secondary entries
> in the data store. So while referring to size one should take redundancy into
> account.
> {quote}
> The region memory consumption and the eviction algorithm are two separate
> concepts, we should not obligate customers to use a custom eviction algorithm
> to report the correct memory consumption for a region.
> We rely on this attribute to show information on PULSE, so neither the member
> memory usage nor cluster memory usage are accurate if the eviction algorithm
> is not configured as {{EvictionAlgorithm.LRU_MEMORY}}.
> To reproduce, start up a cluster with a simple replicated region and insert
> some data. You can check afterwards (from JConsole) that the attribute
> "EntrySize" for the replicated region is set as "-1".
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v7.6.3#76005)