Mirza Aliev created IGNITE-23559:
------------------------------------

             Summary: resetPartitions improvements: two phase reset
                 Key: IGNITE-23559
                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/IGNITE-23559
             Project: Ignite
          Issue Type: Improvement
            Reporter: Mirza Aliev


resetPartitions improvements: two phase reset. Reset to the single most 
up-to-date node and schedule new rebalance with targetTopology that is the 
alive nodes from the current stable assignments


h3. Motivation
According to 
[IEP-131|https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/IGNITE/IEP-131%3A+Partition+Majority+Unavailability+Handling]
 {{DisasterRecoveryManager#resetPartitions}} will be the core method for 
recovering partition majority availability. If only nodes [A, B, C] are alive 
from the partition assignments,   {{NodeImpl#resetPeers}} mechanism will be 
called with the target topology [A, B, C]. 

This approach is wrong, because if {{NodeImpl#resetPeers}} with [A, B, C] will 
be called on nodes A, B, C and {{NodeImpl#resetPeers}}  with [A] will be called 
on node A, it could lead to the situation when we will have two leaders, one 
from B, C because the form majority, and leader A from the configuration [A].

To resolve this problem, {{DisasterRecoveryManager#resetPartitions}} must work 
in two phases: the first phase must call {{NodeImpl#resetPeers}}  only with a 
configuration formed from the single node (with the most up-to-date log, in our 
example it could be A), and after that rebalance on [A, B, C] must be scheduled.

h3. Definition of Done
* resetPartitions must fork in two phases. Reset to the single most up-to-date 
node and schedule new rebalance with targetTopology that is the alive nodes 
from the current stable assignments




--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)

Reply via email to