https://bz.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=120900
--- Comment #9 from Ana Molina Paz <[email protected]> --- (In reply to Ana Molina Paz from comment #8) > I suggest to update the title: > Bullets and Numbering does not remain the same after demoting or promoting > at try to edit them for an MS Office .ppt file > > Summary: > A file that is saved in .ppt format when opened using OpenOffice Impress is > retaining the bullets format, but when we try to edit a bullet by either > promoting or demoting a bullet point it is losing the bullet style. Also for > Numbering bullets and customized alphabet, the next number is not updated > with the previous or next number or letter. > This issue does not happen if the file is saved in the OpenOffice Impress > (.odp) format, and opened and edited using it. > > Testing Environment: > OS: Windows 10 Enterprise 64-bit environment. > Processor: i5-6300 CPU @2.30 GHz and Ram: 8GB > Apache OpenOffice 4.1.7 Impress AOO417m1(Build:9800) - Rev. 46059c9192 > 2019-09-03 12:04 > MS PowerPoint 2019 used to compare with Impress > > Scenario 1: Promote and demote Bullets for a ppt file saved on Impress. > Steps: > 1. Open OpenOffice > 2. Select Presentation > 3. Create a new presentation e.g. using presentation wizard > 4. On the layout add few lines of text > 5. Select all lines > 6. Go to Format>Bullets and Numbering… > 7. Assign any bullets style > 8. Demote few bullet lines by clicking Tab also you can Promote by clicking > Shift + Tab > 9. Go to Files> Save as Type as Microsoft PowerPoint 99/2000/XP (.ppt) > option. > 10. Open the file saved on OpenOffice > 11. Edit the presentation by trying to promote or demote a bullet > > Actual result: The bullet-style changes to some other shape. > Expected result: The Bullets style should remain the same. > > Scenario 2: Promote and demote Bullets for a pptx file saved on MS > PowerPoint 2019. > Steps: > 1. Have a ppt or a pptx file with bullets e.g Testbulletsppt or/and > Testbullletspptx > 2. Open the file saved on OpenOffice > 3. Edit the presentation by trying to promote or demote a bullet > > Actual result: The bullet-style changes to some other shape. > Expected result: The Bullets style should remain the same. > > Follow-up tests: > • Promote and demote Bullets for an ODP file saved on OpenOffice. This issue > is not replicated so It was verified that the Bullets style should remain > the same > • Using other Bullets style using Tab to Demote and Shift-Tab to Promote. > The same issue is replicated > • Using Numbers using Tab to Demote and Shift-Tab to Promote. The same issue > is replicated. Also, the numbering sequence is lost > • Using Graphics bullets using Tab to Demote and Shift-Tab to Promote. The > same issue is replicated > • Using Customize: Alphabets using Tab to Demote and Shift-Tab to Promote. > The same issue is replicated. Also, the numbering sequence is lost > • Using Promote and Demote buttons on the menu bar. This issue couldn’t be > replicated because the Promote and Demote buttons do not enable in the menu > bar. > > Additional findings from the following tests: > 1. I have observed that this problem even happens when trying to save in the > new format .pptx or ppt format and opened with OpenOffice Impress but not > for ODP format. > 2. Not only the bullets are wrong (does not remain the same bullet) Also de > the numbering sequence is not updated at demoting or promoting. > > Compared to Competition: I compare the similar functionality in the MS > office PowerPoint document, and the bullets/Number formatting is retained > when a specific bullet is either promoted or demoted but the size of the > bullets or numbering is not the same. > I also noticed that the open ODP file on PowerPoint loses the bullet promote > or demote format. > > This issue should be fixed because it is important to edit ppt or pptx files > with the correct bullets to have a clear and good presentation and can share > it. For user who use Power Point or OpenOffice or similar This bug is reproducible in a .ppt presentation that was either created in Power Point or Impress application using the comment form arjen.verweij 2014-06-14 23:14:07 UTC I have created attachment Testbulletppt, Testbulletodp and Testbulletpptx -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the issue.
