[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-33635?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=17259399#comment-17259399
]
Jungtaek Lim commented on SPARK-33635:
--------------------------------------
I've spent some time to trace the issue, and noticed SPARK-29054 (+SPARK-30495)
caused performance regression (though the patch itself is doing the right
thing).
{code}
private[kafka010] def getOrRetrieveConsumer(): InternalKafkaConsumer = {
if (!_consumer.isDefined) {
retrieveConsumer()
}
require(_consumer.isDefined, "Consumer must be defined")
if (KafkaTokenUtil.needTokenUpdate(SparkEnv.get.conf,
_consumer.get.kafkaParamsWithSecurity,
_consumer.get.clusterConfig)) {
logDebug("Cached consumer uses an old delegation token, invalidating.")
releaseConsumer()
consumerPool.invalidateKey(cacheKey)
fetchedDataPool.invalidate(cacheKey)
retrieveConsumer()
}
_consumer.get
}
{code}
{code}
def needTokenUpdate(
sparkConf: SparkConf,
params: ju.Map[String, Object],
clusterConfig: Option[KafkaTokenClusterConf]): Boolean = {
if (HadoopDelegationTokenManager.isServiceEnabled(sparkConf, "kafka") &&
clusterConfig.isDefined &&
params.containsKey(SaslConfigs.SASL_JAAS_CONFIG)) {
logDebug("Delegation token used by connector, checking if uses the latest
token.")
val connectorJaasParams =
params.get(SaslConfigs.SASL_JAAS_CONFIG).asInstanceOf[String]
getTokenJaasParams(clusterConfig.get) != connectorJaasParams
} else {
false
}
}
{code}
{code}
def isServiceEnabled(sparkConf: SparkConf, serviceName: String): Boolean = {
val key = providerEnabledConfig.format(serviceName)
deprecatedProviderEnabledConfigs.foreach { pattern =>
val deprecatedKey = pattern.format(serviceName)
if (sparkConf.contains(deprecatedKey)) {
logWarning(s"${deprecatedKey} is deprecated. Please use ${key}
instead.")
}
}
val isEnabledDeprecated = deprecatedProviderEnabledConfigs.forall { pattern
=>
sparkConf
.getOption(pattern.format(serviceName))
.map(_.toBoolean)
.getOrElse(true)
}
sparkConf
.getOption(key)
.map(_.toBoolean)
.getOrElse(isEnabledDeprecated)
}
{code}
With my test data creator, Spark pulled 500 records per a poll from Kafka,
which ended up "10,280,000" calls to get() which always calls
getOrRetrieveConsumer(). A single call of KafkaTokenUtil.needTokenUpdate()
wouldn't add significant overhead, but 10,000,000 calls make a significant
difference. Assuming the case where delegation token is not applied,
HadoopDelegationTokenManager.isServiceEnabled is the culprit on such huge
overhead.
We could probably resolve the issue via short-term solution & long-term
solution.
* short-term solution: change the order of check in needTokenUpdate, so that
the performance hit is only affected when using delegation token. I'll raise a
PR shortly.
* long-term solution(s): 1) optimize
HadoopDelegationTokenManager.isServiceEnabled 2) find a way to reduce the
occurrence of checking necessarily of token update.
Note that even with short-term solution, a slight performance hit is observed
as it still does more things on the code path compared to Spark 2.4. Though I'd
ignore it if it affects slightly, like less than 1%, or even slightly higher
but the code addition is mandatory.
> Performance regression in Kafka read
> ------------------------------------
>
> Key: SPARK-33635
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-33635
> Project: Spark
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SQL
> Affects Versions: 3.0.0, 3.0.1
> Environment: A simple 5 node system. A simple data row of csv data in
> kafka, evenly distributed between the partitions.
> Open JDK 1.8.0.252
> Spark in stand alone - 5 nodes, 10 workers (2 worker per node, each locked to
> a distinct NUMA group)
> kafka (v 2.3.1) cluster - 5 nodes (1 broker per node).
> Centos 7.7.1908
> 1 topic, 10 partiions, 1 hour queue life
> (this is just one of clusters we have, I have tested on all of them and
> theyall exhibit the same performance degredation)
> Reporter: David Wyles
> Priority: Major
>
> I have observed a slowdown in the reading of data from kafka on all of our
> systems when migrating from spark 2.4.5 to Spark 3.0.0 (and Spark 3.0.1)
> I have created a sample project to isolate the problem as much as possible,
> with just a read all data from a kafka topic (see
> [https://github.com/codegorillauk/spark-kafka-read] ).
> With 2.4.5, across multiple runs,
> I get a stable read rate of 1,120,000 (1.12 mill) rows per second
> With 3.0.0 or 3.0.1, across multiple runs,
> I get a stable read rate of 632,000 (0.632 mil) rows per second
> The represents a *44% loss in performance*. Which is, a lot.
> I have been working though the spark-sql-kafka-0-10 code base, but change for
> spark 3 have been ongoing for over a year and its difficult to pin point an
> exact change or reason for the degradation.
> I am happy to help fix this problem, but will need some assitance as I am
> unfamiliar with the spark-sql-kafka-0-10 project.
>
> A sample of the data my test reads (note: its not parsing csv - this is just
> test data)
>
> 1606921800000,001e0610e532,lightsense,tsl250rd,intensity,21853,53.262,acceleration_z,651,ep,290,commit,913,pressure,138,pm1,799,uv_intensity,823,idletime,-372,count,-72,ir_intensity,185,concentration,-61,flags,-532,tx,694.36,ep_heatsink,-556.92,acceleration_x,-221.40,fw,910.53,sample_flow_rate,-959.60,uptime,-515.15,pm10,-768.03,powersupply,214.72,magnetic_field_y,-616.04,alphasense,606.73,AoT_Chicago,053,Racine
> Ave & 18th St Chicago IL,41.857959,-87.65642700000002,AoT Chicago (S)
> [C],2017/12/15 00:00:00,
--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.3.4#803005)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
