[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SVN-4863?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
 ]

seunghyuk.yu updated SVN-4863:
------------------------------
    Description: 
Users are unable to delete sub-folder within a folder with full permission.
 {color:#242729}Path based Authorization File{color}
{panel:title=Authorization File}
[/]

@group02 = rw

[:glob:project:/**]

@group01 = r

[:glob:project:/subProject1/**]

@group01 = rw
{panel}
All users under group2 are able to create or delete any subfolder/files in 
subProject1 while users under group01 are unable to delete any subfolder/files 
with the above permission authorized.

 

For example,

Users under group02 are able to add a folder "subProject1" under folder 
"project":

/project/subProject1

 

Users under group01 are able to add a file "test.txt" under "subProject1": 
/project/subProject1/test.txt

 

Users under group01 are unable to delete any files under "subProject1":

/project/subProject1/test.txt

 

The error msg is 'Access to @path forbidden'.

 

In the previous Subversion 1.9, users under both groups were able to create or 
delete any subfolder/files in the path-based authentication without  ":glob:" 
with above permission authorized.

 subversion version 1.10

  was:
Users are unable to delete sub-folder within a folder with full permission.
 {color:#242729}Path based Authorization File{color}
{panel:title=Authorization File}
[/]

@group02 = rw

[:glob:project:/**]

@group01 = r

[:glob:project:/subProject1/**]

@group01 = rw
{panel}
{color:#242729}Using group02, All the user belonging to group are able to 
create a subfolder/files in subProject1 followed by commit.{color}
 And then using group01, modify a subfolders/files followed by commit *but 
unable to delete a subfolder/files and commit*{color:#242729}. {color}
 It says 'Access to @path forbidden'.
 However group02 are able to delete a subfolder/files.


  
 Subversion 1.9 of path-based authentication without ":glob:" was fine.
  
 {color:#242729}With the above permission{color}
  
 *Using group02,* Adding a folder "subProject1" works 
 /project/subProject1
  
 *Using group01,* {color:#242729}Adding a file "test.txt" works{color} 
/project/subProject1/test.txt
  
 *Using group01,* Deleting a file doesn't works
 /project/subProject1/test.txt
  
 subversion version 1.10


> Unable to delete a subfolder within a folder with RW premission
> ---------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: SVN-4863
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SVN-4863
>             Project: Subversion
>          Issue Type: Bug
>          Components: svnauthz
>    Affects Versions: 1.10.0
>         Environment: subversion V1.10
>            Reporter: seunghyuk.yu
>            Priority: Blocker
>
> Users are unable to delete sub-folder within a folder with full permission.
>  {color:#242729}Path based Authorization File{color}
> {panel:title=Authorization File}
> [/]
> @group02 = rw
> [:glob:project:/**]
> @group01 = r
> [:glob:project:/subProject1/**]
> @group01 = rw
> {panel}
> All users under group2 are able to create or delete any subfolder/files in 
> subProject1 while users under group01 are unable to delete any 
> subfolder/files with the above permission authorized.
>  
> For example,
> Users under group02 are able to add a folder "subProject1" under folder 
> "project":
> /project/subProject1
>  
> Users under group01 are able to add a file "test.txt" under "subProject1": 
> /project/subProject1/test.txt
>  
> Users under group01 are unable to delete any files under "subProject1":
> /project/subProject1/test.txt
>  
> The error msg is 'Access to @path forbidden'.
>  
> In the previous Subversion 1.9, users under both groups were able to create 
> or delete any subfolder/files in the path-based authentication without  
> ":glob:" with above permission authorized.
>  subversion version 1.10



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.3.4#803005)

Reply via email to