[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/YUNIKORN-2532?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
 ]

Yongjun Zhang updated YUNIKORN-2532:
------------------------------------
    Description: 
There is some recent change that caused the application resource usage report 
to have a new format:

Prior the change, the format was:
{code:java}
YK_APP_SUMMARY: {"appID": "app-1", "submissionTime": 1712169262131, 
"startTime": 1712169264134, "finishTime": 1712173619983, "user": "user1", 
"queue": "root.queue-large", "state": "Completed", "rmID": "test-cluster", 
"resourceUsage": 
{"insttype-1":{"memory":139178200478515200,"pods":1729129,"vcore":5183062000},"insttype-2":{"memory":113789789798400,"pods":1413,"vcore":4239000}},
 "preemptedResource": {}}
  {code}
with the change, the new format is:
{code:java}
 2024-04-04T00:33:08.532Z       INFO    core.scheduler.application.usage        
objects/application_summary.go:60       YK_APP_SUMMARY: {ApplicationID: app-2, 
SubmissionTime: 1712190615461, StartTime: 1712190617496, FinishTime: 
1712190788532, User: user2, Queue: root.queue-large, State: Completed, RmID: 
test-cluster, ResourceUsage: 
TrackedResource{UNKNOWN:pods=177,UNKNOWN:vcore=354000,UNKNOWN:memory=1431454089216},
 PreemptedResource: TrackedResource{}, PlaceholderResource: 
TrackedResource{}}{code}
There are several incompatibilities:
1. the class name TrackedResource was not there before, now it is.
2. the instance type was outside the resource part before, not it's embedded
3. the instance type was reported correctly before the change, now it's UNKNOWN

#3 may be a different issue, but it's observed by us at the same time.

I think what should change the format back to the original one, as this is an 
incompatible change. What do you think [~wilfreds] , [~pbacsko] ,[~ccondit] ?

Thanks.

  was:
There is some recent change that caused the application resource usage report 
to have a new format:

Prior the change, the format was:
{code:java}
YK_APP_SUMMARY: {"appID": "adf53ee0-experiment-organicad-94520240-1-1", 
"submissionTime": 1712169262131, "startTime": 1712169264134, "finishTime": 
1712173619983, "user": 
"system:serviceaccount:spark-operator-02:spark-operator", "queue": 
"root.queue-large", "state": "Completed", "rmID": "test-cluster", 
"resourceUsage": 
{"insttype-1":{"memory":139178200478515200,"pods":1729129,"vcore":5183062000},"insttype-2":{"memory":113789789798400,"pods":1413,"vcore":4239000}},
 "preemptedResource": {}}
  {code}
with the change, the new format is:
{code:java}
 2024-04-04T00:33:08.532Z       INFO    core.scheduler.application.usage        
objects/application_summary.go:60       YK_APP_SUMMARY: {ApplicationID: 
afa303d0-test-trino-sparksql--20240404-2-1, SubmissionTime: 1712190615461, 
StartTime: 1712190617496, FinishTime: 1712190788532, User: 
system:serviceaccount:spark-operator-01:spark-operator, Queue: 
root.queue-large, State: Completed, RmID: test-cluster, ResourceUsage: 
TrackedResource{UNKNOWN:pods=177,UNKNOWN:vcore=354000,UNKNOWN:memory=1431454089216},
 PreemptedResource: TrackedResource{}, PlaceholderResource: 
TrackedResource{}}{code}
There are several incompatibilities:
1. the class name TrackedResource was not there before, now it is.
2. the instance type was outside the resource part before, not it's embedded
3. the instance type was reported correctly before the change, now it's UNKNOWN

#3 may be a different issue, but it's observed by us at the same time.

I think what should change the format back to the original one, as this is an 
incompatible change. What do you think [~wilfreds] , [~pbacsko] ,[~ccondit] ?

Thanks.


> Resource usage report has an incompatible format change
> -------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: YUNIKORN-2532
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/YUNIKORN-2532
>             Project: Apache YuniKorn
>          Issue Type: Bug
>          Components: core - scheduler
>            Reporter: Yongjun Zhang
>            Priority: Major
>
> There is some recent change that caused the application resource usage report 
> to have a new format:
> Prior the change, the format was:
> {code:java}
> YK_APP_SUMMARY: {"appID": "app-1", "submissionTime": 1712169262131, 
> "startTime": 1712169264134, "finishTime": 1712173619983, "user": "user1", 
> "queue": "root.queue-large", "state": "Completed", "rmID": "test-cluster", 
> "resourceUsage": 
> {"insttype-1":{"memory":139178200478515200,"pods":1729129,"vcore":5183062000},"insttype-2":{"memory":113789789798400,"pods":1413,"vcore":4239000}},
>  "preemptedResource": {}}
>   {code}
> with the change, the new format is:
> {code:java}
>  2024-04-04T00:33:08.532Z     INFO    core.scheduler.application.usage        
> objects/application_summary.go:60       YK_APP_SUMMARY: {ApplicationID: 
> app-2, SubmissionTime: 1712190615461, StartTime: 1712190617496, FinishTime: 
> 1712190788532, User: user2, Queue: root.queue-large, State: Completed, RmID: 
> test-cluster, ResourceUsage: 
> TrackedResource{UNKNOWN:pods=177,UNKNOWN:vcore=354000,UNKNOWN:memory=1431454089216},
>  PreemptedResource: TrackedResource{}, PlaceholderResource: 
> TrackedResource{}}{code}
> There are several incompatibilities:
> 1. the class name TrackedResource was not there before, now it is.
> 2. the instance type was outside the resource part before, not it's embedded
> 3. the instance type was reported correctly before the change, now it's 
> UNKNOWN
> #3 may be a different issue, but it's observed by us at the same time.
> I think what should change the format back to the original one, as this is an 
> incompatible change. What do you think [~wilfreds] , [~pbacsko] ,[~ccondit] ?
> Thanks.



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to