Gimana kalo yg ini juga dijadiin referensi http://forum.andr.net/viewtopic.php?t=17968&highlight=antivirus
Ini salah satu thread disana: ----------------Start Quote---------------- It was not a testing session just a workshop of ideas .. there are no recommendatios and no conclusions .. it was for 'fun' and additional to the previous AV workshop. PC's .. P4 512mb Ram .. AMD Duron 128mb Ram .. AMD Athlon 1Ghz Ram .. Celeron 256mb Ram .. 8 removable/switchable drive bays .. and borrowed from one of the second hand shops .. P166MMX 32md Ram .. PII 333 128Mb Ram .. HDD's as fitted O/S 95R2 .. 98Final .. XP .. XPSP1 .. (original MS and 'warez' copies) No Linux !! AV's .. Nortons, McAfee, NOD32, F-Prot, DrWeb, Avast, Kaspersky, RAV, BitDefender, EZ Trust, PC-Cillin, Panda, Sophos, QuickHeal, Norman, Vet, Ahnlab and GeCad .. versions latest available confirmed by email from supplier .. (2 did not reply .. NOD32 and QuickHeal) 5 teams .. rota basis for each PC (4 main .. 4 days .. 7 graphics cards, 9 motherboards, 3 modem chipsets ..) Questionaire .. use you imagination So all started well .. Install and 'user' face .. Then just simple 'catchme' .. Followed by 'sneaky' End day one .. goodbye to Sophos, Quickheal and Avast .. for various reasons not just ability but 'looks and use' End day two .. farewell to GeCad, F-Prot, RAV, Ahnlab and Panda (bit of a surprise that one!) Day three .. Ratties turn .. multiple attacks and 'catch me' .. Oh! dear!! Very mixed results .. OK! the chances of a multiple attack are very rare but a good test. My next trick 'black death' .. Painful to watch but fun! Day four .. An armageddon for any AV .. I destroyed them .. better than any game. Test for 'warez' updates .. check financial status of supplier .. So here is the result (not in any order) Nortons .. resources hungry but folks it just outranked the rest and I mean outranked. There was not one other AV came anywhere near the stability, effectiveness and reliability of this product .. updates no problem (And a big thank you to Nortons for paying my hotel bill and new wardrobe of clothes .. just joking!!!) NOD32 .. for the average user no probs but the 'hassle' even for IT to get updates makes this a poor choice .. it is no more effective than other AV's and under a multiple attack crashed the PC's except for XP which totally refused to work after reset EZ Trust .. this AV has come a long way since I last knew it. Definitely as good as Nortons but good to 'look at and use' .. updates no problem .. (more uptodate engine than Vet) KasperskyPro .. what can I say .. with the V1 anti-hacker firewall and their new independence from the eastern block co-op .. very good and well liked by all the teams if a little tricky to use .. updates no problems BitDefender .. OK! but not a first choice PC-Cillin .. good product but we had problems getting updates .. It did give two false alarms DrWeb .. version 4.29 definitely has problems .. already two patches and another expected. It was tops for false alarms!! An email response was that work had already started for v4.30 and DS expected to be independent also shortly .. With the Agnitum firewall this is one good combination .. updates no problems McAfee .. In a race 'third' behind Nortons and EZ but still a good product and in use here at IT on all the public access PC's .. it just seems to work and is 'there' .. the firewall is a good bonus and can be easily configured .. updates no problems Vet .. no adverse comments .. same 'stable' as EZ but not the same engine .. EZ better choice Financially .. Nortons, McAfee, EZ and Kaspersky (I know it's russian!) no problems .. DrWeb (limited info but seems OK) .. PC-Cillin (AV sales down but group stable) .. NOD32 (having a rough time .. 2002 was not good .. 2003 predictions downcast .. blame 'warez' and non renewals by clients) Questionaire .. Brand Name ? Nortons (now there's a surprise!) Trusted Product ? Nortons Buy? Nortons (OK! now it's getting boring) Use at Home/Work ? Nortons Would change ? 80% = NO Successful Attacks ? None Attacks reported in 12,317 questionaires = 26 .. 19 people did not use an AV or firewall!! Of the other 7, 6 used Nortons, 1 could not remember, but all stopped at entry. Eastern Europe .. Nortons (big surprise but Kaspersky was known) Scandinavia .. Nortons and McAfee Africa .. EZ, Kaspersky and DrWeb (that's new!) America/Canada .. Nortons, McAfee, EZ and Kaspersky Australia .. McAfee, Kaspersky and Nortons (NOD32 is not liked because of its difficulty in obtaining updates, poor customer support and using the Aussie connection for sales at home) Europe .. Guess? Clue starts with N ends with s .. 7 letters. EZ and McAfee Far East .. (majority here Thai) Kaspersky, Nortons and DrWeb. McAfee trailed along as well MiddleEast/Others .. Beat me with a soggy fish I confess .. Nortons and McAfee That's it folks there be no more! What's Rattie say? As well as detecting a virus the prog needs easy access to def updates and financial stability. Nortons, EZ, McAfee, Kaspersky are no doubt the ones most favoured. However, as soon as DrWeb 4.30 comes along I'll give it a try with Agnitum OutPost. Members, you can say what you like but the fact is Nortons is in a class of its own! The other AV's are a personal choice for members .. I specifically make no recommendations or conclusions!! Off topic .. Kerio firewall (the free version is as good as the one you have to pay for .. big thank you to Kerio) Credits .. thanks to all the teams, to 'goldfish' the best of a bunch, to a major (not intel) CPU manf, monitor supplier, and data store for the 'give away goodies' .. a english language school for supplying senior students, and the HDD manf who paid all the expenses for food and drink. Friends in London, US and Oz for the financial data. Lastly to IT .. without this facility none of this would have happened and the 12,000+ visitors over 4 days who took time to fill in the questionaire OK .. this has been posted at other user groups but not any other forum Please if you want pass it on .. I do not want any credit .. that goes to the teams .... I've have already thanked them Don't email me or I'll spam you .. I will not answer any individual questions so don't post them .. If you have access to the same type of facilities and want to continue then please go ahead and share with this forum and any other interested groups Please read post 'dangerous new threat' .. they want to drag me out of retirement for this one ... NO CHANCE!!!!!! The Rat ----------------End Quote---------------- Regards Setyo On Sun, 26 Dec 2004 16:28:50 +0700, Harnanto <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Rangking Antivirus menurut sebuah website virus collector bisa dilihat disini: > http://www.virus.gr/english/fullxml/default.asp?id=67&mnu=67 > > lumayan bisa dijadikan salah satu bahan pertimbangan memilih antivirus > yang baik. -- www.ITCENTER.or.id - Komunitas Teknologi Informasi Indonesia Info, Gabung, Keluar, Mode Kirim : [EMAIL PROTECTED] ::: Hapus bagian yang tidak perlu (footer, dst) saat reply! ::: ## Forum: ITCENTER.or.id/forum ## Jobs: ITCENTER.or.id/jobs ## Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ITCENTER/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
