> -----Original Message----- > From: Xavier Hanin [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: lundi 25 juin 2007 16:47 > To: [email protected] > Subject: Re: Ivy settings management from Ant (was Re: can i call > ivy:configure multiple times with different configuration files(which in > turn refers different ivy.xmls)?) > > On 6/25/07, Gilles Scokart <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > I think I was not clear in my explanations, sorry. > > What I would like to have is : > > > > - When deprecated <configure> is used, no scoping is > > available. settingsRef > > in task doesn't make sense > > > Does it mean that if you use settingsRef in a task it will raise an error? > Even if you use settingsRef="ivy.instance"? I thought the call to > configure > with no id was equivalent to <ivy:settings id="ivy.instance"/>. Is it > right?
Currently on the trunk, yes, you are right. I just said that it didn't make sense, so for me it could raise an error or we could keep the current behaviour. I'm too tired today to say which approach I would prefer. > > - When a <settings> is defined, id='...' is mandatory. And an error (with > a > > clear message) is triggered when a task try to use the settings > > 'ivy.instance' (implicitely or or not) and this instance was created > with > > a > > <settings> without id. > > > Sorry, I'm not sure to fully understand this point. Do you mean that: > <ivy:settings /> > <ivy:resolve settingsRef="ivy.instance" /> > will raise a clear error, saying that the id is mandatory in settings? > > In this case, what happen if you do this: > <ivy:configure file="ivyconf.xml"/> > <ivy:resolve /> > <ivy:settings file="ivysettings.xml" /> > <ivy:resolve settingsRef="ivy.instance" /> > ? > The first resolve should run ok with the settings loaded from ivyconf.xml. > Then will the second resolve use the first settings loaded with configure, > the second one, or raise an error? My guess is that it will use the first > settings. Am I right? > Currently on the trunk, again you are right. But I'm not sure it is intuitive. I would prefer the second resolve call trigger an error saying that the ivy:settings must have an id. Gilles
