Hi Mike, William et al,

2010/4/7 m...@watty <[email protected]>:
>
>
>> We can actually do both C and Python for awhile and maybe you'll come
>> to like Python.
Would it take much effort to generate a c-output? If so, I'd like to
receive it and take a look.

> I'm still confused as to why this is got anything to do with Jallib or
> jal.
It would allow you to write jal programs and run them on any system
with a c-compliler. I'd expec you'd like this - more jal and less c ;)

> If it works on 18F why port it to any other chip?
Why would you use JAL for 18F while there is a good C compiler? It is
on 16F chips that JAL provides real added value, since afaik JAL has
better quality than the C compilers.

> If you really need an ARM, x86 or MIPS (PIC32) (forget the other
> processors mostly and possibly MIPS too) and not an 18F, it's likely
> you need an OS too. I see little value in porting existing JAL code.
I don't think this is universally true - many of those chips don't
have the memory or processing power for a real os, but that's besided
the issue. Like this you can use JAL to write programs for operating
systems too.

> Translated code is a terrible basis for a new project, esp. to C where
> there is no shortage of Libraries for ARM, MIPS (PIC32) and x86.
It's not a basis for a project, C is used as portable assembler ;)

> I've looked at PIC16 C compilers compared with JAL. There is no reason
> whatsover you would use C on 16F and 18F if you have a Jal programmer
> and compiler.
Well... C has structures, enums, pointers (so you can have objects). I
know you'll reply 'C is evil', but it provides many powerfull features
you'd like to have in JAL...

> Of course maybe I have totally misunderstood what the purpose of this
> is.
As you may have deduced, I would never have used JAL if there was a
good C compiler for 16f back in 2003 and would be seriously tempted to
switch if there was one now.
For me, this is hobby, which is the purpose on it's own. I am not
interessted in the jal-to-c converter as the result, but in the
creation of such a converter.

Joep

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"jallib" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/jallib?hl=en.

Reply via email to