> Could you setup user in-boxes to include the domain on multidomain
> systems?

As I said earlier:

> > But that doesn't prevent the use of the whole address, however doing so
> > would require changes to local delivery.

> Another cleaner, but more involved change would be to map
> domains in user repositories either in subdirs or in
> naming conventions for the file.

That's just it ... there is no file, necessarily.  There is a repository
abstraction.  There is one kind of repository built on the file system, and
another build on JDBC.  So what you want to deal with is the abtract model.
The local-part is used as a key into the store.  Also, don't forget that
people often want to map multiple addresses into one.  I'm not convinced,
that a virtual user table doesn't provide much of what people need; it
certainly does the trick for SendMail.  So I do think that revisiting the
user repository model is a good idea, but I'd sooner see it done
comprehensively than patchwork.

> I understand that portion, what I'm looking for is another option to the
> "black-hole" method.

I understand.  I watch SPAM spool into my system all the time, and have been
cataloging strings to delete them, so that we can parse out any legitimately
misdirected e-mail from the volumes of SPAM.  As I mentioned last week
(check the archives), I'm thinking of a shared object in the MailetContext
that can be used to inform the SMTP Handler about users to be refused.  That
way, it could refuse service and terminate them, e.g., issue a 421 and hang
up.

Actually, I'd prefer to be able to do handle spammers in iptables, and
discard their request thus consuming THEIR resources for a change, but
iptables isn't scalable.

> by reporting back that the user doesn't exist, the spammer
> will stop trying to send

No, actually, they'll use you to identify which addresses ARE valid.

As for the rest of what you said, it is a bit naive, unfortunately.  You've
no idea of the scope and scale of spam operations, and the techniques they
use to try to get under your radar.  Visit news:news.admin.net-abuse.email.


> I hate spam so much, I plan on creating a site to report

See spews, spamcop, ordb, and many many MANY other sites.

        --- Noel


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Reply via email to