>1.5 IS the Java version that the majority Lucene users use, not 1.4!
>Does this mean we can now start accepting 1.5 code?
This isn't simply about which JVM gets used the most wins.
This is about "how many Lucene users will we inconvenience or lose by
moving to 1.5?"
Right now the survey sample tells me roughly a third which doesn't seem
like a good thing. Maybe the question is more usefully "who can't/won't
move to 1.5 in the immediate future?"
I believe we shouldn't select the minimum platform based on the coding
convenience it may offer us which seems to be the major objective behind
1.5 adoption. When developing a library deployed in many
applications/environments over which you have no control and where
careful consideration of runtime performance not coding
convenience/speed of development is the primary concern my preference
would be to choose 1.4.
Not all deployment environments can be upgraded easily. Take my current
application at work. It's applet-based and rolled out to hundreds of
corporate desktops which are stuck on 1.4 (this won't change anytime
soon). Lucene isn't on the client but all client and server code in the
app has been written in 1.4 to avoid any issues of any 1.5 code leaking
onto the 1.4 client. All of the many 3rd party libraries in use (Spring,
database drivers etc) are 1.4 compatible in their latest versions. I'd
like to stick with the latest Lucene codebase but mandating 1.5 for
Lucene would introduce a code management headache to this app with the
mixed JVMs
Unless there are *really* good runtime benefits that are solely based on
1.5 libraries or source code I would prefer to see Lucene stick with 1.4
as a base rather than limit Lucene's deployment options simply because
of code-time benefits the new 1.5 syntax offers.
I see that the Spring framework recognise this dilemma and still seek to
support as far back as 1.3 (see http://www.springframework.org/node/220).
Simon said "everyone should download 1.5". It's nice to think you can
accelerate the global adoption of 1.5 by changing projects like Lucene
but the reality is corporates do not change platforms overnight because
of such a change.
That's a long-winded way of saying "-1" unless I hear of any arguments
which are based on something much more substantial than "1.5 makes
coding easier".
Cheers,
Mark
___________________________________________________________
The all-new Yahoo! Mail goes wherever you go - free your email address from your Internet provider. http://uk.docs.yahoo.com/nowyoucan.html
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
