Jon,
1. The patch has become a tad bit outdated after to your recent push.
Just a heads-up.
2.
145 if (locale == Locale.getDefault()) {
That looks very conservative, I would expect `equals()`. Since it's about
a one-off optimization, it is not a big deal. I just stumbled upon that.
Thanks for small cleanups along the way.
Looks good to me.
-Pavel
> On 6 Feb 2020, at 19:26, Jonathan Gibbons <jonathan.gibb...@oracle.com> wrote:
>
> Please review a change to use separate locales for messages written to the
> console and for content written in the generated HTML pages.
>
> Background: although the command-line help is not very informative about how
> the -locale option is used, the man page is clear that it is clear that the
> option affects the generated documentation.
>
> Command-line help:
>
> -locale <name>
> Locale to be used, e.g. en_US or en_US_WIN
>
> Man page:
>
> `-locale` *name*
> : Specifies the locale that the `javadoc` tool uses when it generates
> documentation. The argument is the name of the locale, as described in
> `java.util.Locale` documentation, such as `en_US` (English, United States)
> or `en_US_WIN` (Windows variant).
>
> With the proposed change, the -locale option only affects the generated
> documentation; it does not affect console output, which will use the default
> locale, in line with other JDK tools.
>
>
>
> The changes ...
>
> The core of the change is in HtmlConfiguration, which creates the resource
> bundles for the Messages object (used to generate console messages) and for
> Configuration.getResources(), which is used to get the resources for content
> in the generated output. To clarify the distinction,
> BaseConfiguration.getResources is renamed to
> BaseConfiguration.getDocResources, to emphasise that it is to be used for
> resources in the generated documentation. This rename percolates through most
> of the other affected files. The rename also highlighted some issues in
> HtmlOptions, which were using the low-level reporter and resources API to
> generate messaages, instead of using the Messages API. These have now been
> fixed.
>
> The tests ...
>
> There's a somewhat surprising test case in TestSearch, which was testing the
> search feature when using Japanese and Chinese locales. The primary part of
> these test cases seems to be that the locale setting does *not* affect the
> generated search index files, but perhaps as a control to verify the locale
> option is taking effect, the test cases also verify some of the output
> generated by javadoc. It's not clear how useful the test cases are, but
> rather than simply remove them, each one is split in two: one to set the
> default locale, and one to use the locale option.
>
> The primary test update is the recently-new TestLocaleOption.java, which is
> updated to be able to test the use of the default locale and the locale
> option. The test is refactored a bit to share more of the common code for the
> different test cases.
>
>
>
> Additional work ...
>
> The command-line help and man page should be improved. The man page states
> that the -locale option should be first on the command line, which is no
> longer the case.
> The change should probably have a release note.
>
>
>
> -- Jon
>
>
>
> JBS: https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8238437
> Webrev: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~jjg/8238437/webrev/
>
>
>
>
>
