Greg Wilkins wrote: > Well firstly I'm going to say that we have been having problems > with jboss role based authentication for some time. It is not > something that we want to get wrong, so I think the time has long > since passed where we need a good set of regression tests for > this. > > Now, while I can see that subsequent requests will be in different > threads - I cannot see where the second thread is coming from > within the same request???? > > Nowhere in the Jetty handling or the JBoss adaptor is a new thread > created, let alone for a call to the authentication API?
Likewise, I do not create any extra threads in the integration code. Perhaps the Servlet itself is creating it ? Is it demonstrating programmatic security rather than declarative ? If so, then this is a problem, unless security info attached to primary request threads can be transparently inherited, in user code, by it's child threads.... Jules > > > As the JBoss JaasSecurityManager class appears to use ThreadLocals > to store authentication results then the solution may have to be to > authenticate every request rather than just relying on the contents > of a session to show that it has previously been authenticated. > > Note this probably means that we also have to deauthenticate threads when > they are returned to the thread pool. I can't see how Jetty can help > much here, as ThreadLocals are beyond it's control and can't > be cleared by it. I would say that adorning Threads with security > priviledges does not sound too robust in any environment that uses > thread pools (Ie almost any servlet container). > > I don't know enough about the jboss authentication mechanism to really > comment more - but I'll repeat that we should make security issues top > priority. > > regards > > Julian Gosnell wrote: > > > Anatoly, > > > > Thanks for the precise description of the problem. I shall take a look at > > this as soon as I find the time. Probably during the first week of Jan or so. > > > > Greg, > > > > Any thoughts about this before I plunge in ? > > > > Jules > > > > > > Anatoly Akkerman wrote: > > > > > >>Hi, guys > >> > >>I am running into problems with Jetty + JBoss 3.0alpha > >> > >>After some debugging here is what I have. > >> > >>Setup: > >>Jetty + JBoss 3.0 > >>Sun's Petstore 1.1.1 deployed piecewise (meaning each EJB and WAR are > >>packaged separately and deployed in a J2eeScopedDeployer) > >>JBossSX configured to pick up usernames, password and roles from files > >> > >>Here is what happens: > >> > >>1) a servlet in Petstore takes username and password from a Web form and > >>sets "j_username" and "j_password" in the session. Jetty seems to pick > >>this stuff up and pass it to JBossUserRealm to authenticate the user. > >>JbossUserPrincipal gets created and then proceeds to authenticate with > >>with _securityMgr (which is JaasSecurityManager "java:/jaas/other"). > >>Authentication succeeds, I see a log and I did doublecheck that > >>JaasSecurityManager sets activeSubject to this authenticated subject. > >> > >>2) Then, it seems, Jetty proceeds to check that this user has required > >>roles. It first calls JbossUserRealm.getUser(name) to obtain the > >>JBossUserPricipal and then calls isUserInRole(String role). This is where > >>the stuff fails miserably. The reason being that Jetty dispatched a > >>different thread to do role checking than the one that did > >>authentication. Because of this, JaasSecurityManager sees a null > >>activeSubject and says that the user does not have required roles. > >> > >>Now, this happens in a _single_ http request from a web client (just > >>clicked 'login' button on a form). I can try hacking a workaround just for > >>my demo to work but would like to help fixing this if it is a bug. > >> > >>------------------------------------------------------------------------- > >>Anatoly Akkerman > >>Computer Science Dept. > >>Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, NYU > >>715 Broadway, #719 Tel: 212 998-3493 > >>New York, NY 10003 Fax: 212 995-4123 > >>------------------------------------------------------------------------- > >> > >>_______________________________________________ > >>Jboss-development mailing list > >>[EMAIL PROTECTED] > >>https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development > >> > > > > > > _________________________________________________________ > > Do You Yahoo!? > > Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com > > > > > > > > For the latest information about Jetty, please see http://jetty.mortbay. > > > > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ > > > > > > -- > Greg Wilkins<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> GB Phone: +44-(0)7092063462 > Mort Bay Consulting Australia and UK. Mbl Phone: +61-(0)4 17786631 > http://www.mortbay.com AU Phone: +61-(0)2 98107029 > > ------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ---------------------~--> > FREE COLLEGE MONEY > CLICK HERE to search > 600,000 scholarships! > http://us.click.yahoo.com/G_L2TD/4m7CAA/ySSFAA/CefplB/TM > ---------------------------------------------------------------------~-> > > For the latest information about Jetty, please see http://jetty.mortbay. > > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ _________________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com _______________________________________________ Jboss-development mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development
