Peter Saint-Andre wrote:
Norman Rasmussen wrote:I don't mind if it's 'SHOULD or MUST' NOT, but I think that '_xmppconnect IN TXT "_xmpp-client-tcp"' should be removed from the list of Example 1. TXT Resource Records, and perhaps listed directly with Business Rule 3.1Oh, I see what you mean. All that the TXT record says is: "Among the connection methods I support is _xmpp-client-tcp, but if you want to know the port number then use the usual SRV lookup mechanism". However, the TXT records provide a complete list of the supported connection methods. Is that confusing? I suppose it is possible for the TXT records and SRV records to get out of sync in this case as well (though it's just as possible for the TXT record to say that a WAP connection method is supported and for the WAP admin to shut that off, so I don't know that the two cases are all that different).
Hmm, now that I think about it some more the _xmpp-client-tcp information probably doesn't belong in a TXT record at all, but I'll talk with my co-author about that before removing it.
/psa
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
