On 23 Apr 2023, at 22:44, Rob Bygrave <robin.bygr...@gmail.com<mailto:robin.bygr...@gmail.com>> wrote:
So if app module A uses Y it will have: requires y. If app module A uses X and Y it will have: requires x; requires y; requires y.inject; We now need everyone using x and y together to explicitly know that y also provides a plugin and that they ALSO must remember to add the requires x.inject; (and x.inject has no exports, it only has the provides). Have I understood correctly? Not quite. If it uses X and Y it will have:: requires x; requires y; uses x.Plugin; which is exactly what you wanted, no? (You don’t even need `requires y` if Y’s other functionality is not used directly). The y.inject module can be on the module path whether or not the application has X. It’s just not resolved unless some module `uses x.Plugin`, and to do that it must also `requires x` since that’s the module that defines the service interface `x.Plugin`. — Ron