[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-21277?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
 ]

Maros Orsak updated KAFKA-21277:
--------------------------------
    Description: 
The Docker image can only run controllers with static voters. With 
controller.quorum.bootstrap.servers instead:
 # KafkaDockerWrapper always formats with plain kafka-storage format. On a 
controller without voters, StorageTool requires --standalone or 
--no-initial-controllers, so the format fails and the container exits.
 # The image configure script rejects KAFKA_ADVERTISED_LISTENERS on 
controller-only nodes, but a dynamic voter needs an advertised controller 
endpoint.

We should (i.) add a new env var (e.g. STORAGE_FORMAT_ARGS) appended to the 
images format command and (ii.) allow KAFKA_ADVERTISED_LISTENERS on controllers 
when it lists only controller listeners.

Default behaviour stays unchanged. Since the env vars are part of the images, 
interface (KIP-975), this might require a small KIP.

Affects the 3.9.x+ version.

  was:
The Docker image can only run controllers with static voters. With 
controller.quorum.bootstrap.servers instead:
 # KafkaDockerWrapper always formats with plain kafka-storage format. On a 
controller without voters, StorageTool requires --standalone or 
--no-initial-controllers, so the format fails and the container exits.
 # The image configure script rejects KAFKA_ADVERTISED_LISTENERS on 
controller-only nodes, but a dynamic voter needs an advertised controller 
endpoint.

 

We should (i.) add a new env var (e.g. STORAGE_FORMAT_ARGS) appended to the 
images format command and (ii.) allow KAFKA_ADVERTISED_LISTENERS on controllers 
when it lists only controller listeners.

Default behaviour stays unchanged. Since the env vars are part of the images, 
interface (KIP-975), this might require a small KIP.

Affects the 3.9.x+ version.


> Docker image: support KRaft dynamic quorum (KIP-853) controllers
> ----------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: KAFKA-21277
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-21277
>             Project: Kafka
>          Issue Type: Improvement
>            Reporter: Maros Orsak
>            Assignee: Maros Orsak
>            Priority: Major
>
> The Docker image can only run controllers with static voters. With 
> controller.quorum.bootstrap.servers instead:
>  # KafkaDockerWrapper always formats with plain kafka-storage format. On a 
> controller without voters, StorageTool requires --standalone or 
> --no-initial-controllers, so the format fails and the container exits.
>  # The image configure script rejects KAFKA_ADVERTISED_LISTENERS on 
> controller-only nodes, but a dynamic voter needs an advertised controller 
> endpoint.
> We should (i.) add a new env var (e.g. STORAGE_FORMAT_ARGS) appended to the 
> images format command and (ii.) allow KAFKA_ADVERTISED_LISTENERS on 
> controllers when it lists only controller listeners.
> Default behaviour stays unchanged. Since the env vars are part of the images, 
> interface (KIP-975), this might require a small KIP.
> Affects the 3.9.x+ version.



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)

Reply via email to