[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-9291?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
dengziming updated KAFKA-9291:
------------------------------
Description:
KAFKA-9288 add some code which I didn't now fully understand, but it indeed
bring some bug which is serious and I debugged the process:
1. when consumer client start, an `ApiVersionsRequest` are send
2. KafkaApis. handleApiVersionsRequest(request) are invoke
3. ApiVersionsResponse.createApiVersionsResponse()
4. and it will add all `ApiVersionsResponseKey` to
`ApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection`
5. every time add an element will return false! ( *this is where the bug is*,
but I didn't find the reason)
!image-2019-12-11-19-23-04-499.png!
6. after the for loop, the `ApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection` is EMPTY!
!image-2019-12-11-19-28-29-559.png!
7. when the Client receive the response, ERROR will occur.
!image-2019-12-11-19-29-28-156.png!
8. and my application was terminated
!image-2019-12-11-19-29-53-353.png!
So we can conclude that the reason is the new code of
inApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection
was:
KAFKA-9288 add some code which I didn't now fully understand, but it indeed
bring some bug which is serious and I debugged the process:
1. when consumer client start, an `ApiVersionsRequest` are send
2. KafkaApis. handleApiVersionsRequest(request) are invoke
3. ApiVersionsResponse.createApiVersionsResponse()
4. and it will add all `ApiVersionsResponseKey` to
`ApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection`
5. every time add an element will return false!( I didn't find the reason)
!image-2019-12-11-19-23-04-499.png!
6. after the for loop, the `ApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection` is EMPTY!
!image-2019-12-11-19-28-29-559.png!
7. when the Client receive the response, ERROR will occur.
!image-2019-12-11-19-29-28-156.png!
8. and my application was terminated
!image-2019-12-11-19-29-53-353.png!
> remove the code of KAFKA-9288 which bring fatal bug
> ---------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: KAFKA-9291
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-9291
> Project: Kafka
> Issue Type: Improvement
> Reporter: dengziming
> Assignee: dengziming
> Priority: Blocker
> Attachments: image-2019-12-11-19-23-04-499.png,
> image-2019-12-11-19-28-29-559.png, image-2019-12-11-19-29-28-156.png,
> image-2019-12-11-19-29-53-353.png
>
>
> KAFKA-9288 add some code which I didn't now fully understand, but it indeed
> bring some bug which is serious and I debugged the process:
> 1. when consumer client start, an `ApiVersionsRequest` are send
> 2. KafkaApis. handleApiVersionsRequest(request) are invoke
> 3. ApiVersionsResponse.createApiVersionsResponse()
> 4. and it will add all `ApiVersionsResponseKey` to
> `ApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection`
> 5. every time add an element will return false! ( *this is where the bug is*,
> but I didn't find the reason)
> !image-2019-12-11-19-23-04-499.png!
>
> 6. after the for loop, the `ApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection` is EMPTY!
> !image-2019-12-11-19-28-29-559.png!
>
> 7. when the Client receive the response, ERROR will occur.
> !image-2019-12-11-19-29-28-156.png!
>
> 8. and my application was terminated
> !image-2019-12-11-19-29-53-353.png!
>
> So we can conclude that the reason is the new code of
> inApiVersionsResponseKeyCollection
--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.3.4#803005)
