--- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> LOL, Catherine...
> 
> That one actually flew off before I could write it.

I knew that - I was just havin' fun with ya!

> But I think her writing reflects that Christmas is
> just one more thing that doesn't live up to the
> hype. 
> 
> Why else would she throw the Christmas reference
> into "Chinese Cafe", except to set up the contrast
> of the supposed joy of the season against her own
> melancholia? 
> 

I agree.  And River is the ultimate Christmas downer
(in a way).  "It's coming on Christmas/They're cutting
down trees/ They're putting up reindeer/ And singing
songs of joy and peace/ Oh, I wish I had a river I
could skate away on..."

It's not about the wonderful Christmas tree and how
pretty it is - it's about cutting down trees.  And
putting up reindeer?  Sounds like maybe they're being
crucified! (Maybe I'm going too far with that -
depends on what kind of a mood I'm in at the time!) 
There's also kind of a bitterness in her voice when
she sings that song - and then, she wants to just
skate away from it all.  Jeez, what a great song for
bringing out the melancholy!

The other day, they were playing something they call
disc-lexia on one of our local radio stations, and
they played Robert Downey Jr's version of River - when
he sings "they're cutting down trees", it really
sounds like "they're cutting down cheese!" which kind
of ruins the mood - however, if you have a sick sense
of humour, it works.


______________________________________________________ 
Send your holiday cheer with http://greetings.yahoo.ca

Reply via email to