Fred wrote:

> This may be heresy to some, but Neil's songwriting has become less and
less
> interesting to me over the years. But this is true of a lot of writers
from
> back then, including C, S, and N.

Not heresy, just opinion!  I have the same opinion about Stephen Stills, who
is one of my heroes.  His early song-writing, eg. For What It's Worth, Word
Game, Helplessly Hoping, was exceptional, but I'm afraid his lyrics have not
improved with the years (unlike his guitar-playing which is still
incredible).

Compare the lyrics from Word Game (about apartheid in South Africa):

Would you knock a man down if you don't like the cut of his clothes
Could you put a man away if you don't want to hear what he knows
Well it's happening right here, people dying of fear by the droves

with the lyrics from Drivin' Thunder

And I ain't too good with numbers
And I've run out of fuel
Here comes another corner baby
Let me demonstrate my slide rule (slide rule)

Obviously I've taken two extremes, and he is still capable of writing some
good songs!  Nash and Crosby have not "deteriorated" as much IMO, and Crosby
in particular is still writing some good stuff.

I guess it comes back to one of the other reasons I love Joni so much.  The
lyrics are as strong and meaningful as they were 30 years ago.

Hell
____________________________
"To have great poets, there must be
great audiences too." - Walt Whitman

[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Visit the NBLs (Natural Born Losers) at:
http://homepages.ihug.co.nz/~hell/

Reply via email to