Please provide more information: - Translator addresses and routing table - Client addresses and routing table - Any routers between them? Addresses and routing tables - Jool configuration - Exact ping command you're trying to run, and output
On Mon, May 11, 2020 at 7:40 AM Kunal Chauhan <[email protected]> wrote: > > Hi Team, > > 1.earlier my jool machine was working with as IPv6 to ipv4 . > > 2. But if I am going to ping through IPV6 to IPV6 via jool it is not > working.at same time. > > please guide > > > Thanks > Kunal > > On Wed, Apr 22, 2020 at 1:27 AM Kunal Chauhan <[email protected]> > wrote: >> >> First of all a BIG THANK YOU Alberto ! with your support my first run is >> successful. >> I may come to you again if any thing more clarity require regarding jool >> network etc. >> >> On Wed, Apr 22, 2020 at 1:26 AM Kunal Chauhan <[email protected]> >> wrote: >>> >>> First of all a BIG THANK YOU Alberto ! with your support my first run is >>> successful. >>> I may come to you again if any thing more clarity require regarding jool >>> network etc. >>> >>> On Wed, Apr 22, 2020 at 12:33 AM Alberto Leiva <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >>>> It seems you're confusing "NAT64 network" and "IPv6 network." >>>> Let's give everything proper names: >>>> >>>> Your "NAT64 network" is the pool6 network. This is the IPv6 prefix you >>>> will mask your IPv4 nodes with. >>>> Your "IPv6 network" is every other IPv6 network. It can be composed of >>>> several subnetworks. It contains your IPv6 node and your translator, >>>> and they don't even need to be in the same subnetwork. >>>> >>>> There are only two constraints: >>>> - Your IPv6 node's address MUST NOT be inside the NAT64 network. >>>> - Your translator's NIC address MUST NOT be inside the NAT64 network. >>>> You can satisfy these requirements in many different ways. >>>> >>>> Suppose your organization's network is 2001:ab5::/32. >>>> You can assign 2001:ab5::/96 as the "NAT64 network". >>>> Then the IPv6 node and the translator can have any address from >>>> 2001:ab5::/32 which is not in 2001:ab5::/96. >>>> In other words, if the IPv6 node and the translator share network >>>> 2001:ab5:0:1::/64, then 2001:ab5:0:1::160 and 2001:ab5:0:1::205 are >>>> perfectly adequate for the IPv6 node and the translator. >>>> >>>> But notice that, if the IPv6 node and the translator are not in the >>>> same network, then you need to adjust your routing to make sure the >>>> pool6 traffic arrives to the translator instead of some other gateway. >>>> But if they are in the same network, it's as simple as telling the >>>> IPv6 node to send packets to the NAT64 network via the translator: >>>> >>>> ip -6 route add 64:ff9b::/96 via 2001:ab5:0:1::160 >>>> >>>> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 1:39 PM Kunal Chauhan <[email protected]> >>>> wrote: >>>> > >>>> > Then point is not clear how I will treat or make jool and ipv6 node at >>>> > different network. ? >>>> > because my jool machine address is as below: >>>> > 1. 2001:ab5:0:1::160 >>>> > and IPv6 machine is 2001:ab5:0:1::205. >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > On Wed, Apr 22, 2020 at 12:00 AM Alberto Leiva <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >>>> >> > 1. IPV6 machine is ip address is 2001:ab5:0:1::205 then what is >>>> >> > 2001:ab5:0:1::/64 ? you are talking >>>> >> >>>> >> When you assign IPv6 machine's IPv6 address, you also have to assign a >>>> >> prefix: >>>> >> >>>> >> ip address add 2001:ab5:0:1::205/64 dev eth0 >>>> >> >>>> >> I'm assuming that number (the network prefix) is 64, because network >>>> >> administrators usually use 64. But in this case, it can also easily be >>>> >> any number between 65 and 96. >>>> >> >>>> >> If your address is 2001:ab5:0:1::205/64, then the network is >>>> >> 2001:ab5:0:1::/64. >>>> >> If your address is 2001:ab5:0:1::205/96, then the network is >>>> >> 2001:ab5:0:1::/96. >>>> >> >>>> >> That's what I'm talking about. >>>> >> >>>> >> > 2. Jool's IPv6 address is 2001:ab5:0:1::160 so then >>>> >> > 2001:ab5:0:1::205 and 2001:ab5:0:1::160 appears in same network ? >>>> >> >>>> >> Yes, assuming the network prefix is between 0-118. If it's 119+, then >>>> >> no. >>>> >> >>>> >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 1:21 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> > >>>> >> > Query: require elaboration >>>> >> > 1. IPV6 machine is ip address is 2001:ab5:0:1::205 then what is >>>> >> > 2001:ab5:0:1::/64 ? you are talking >>>> >> > >>>> >> > 2. Jool's IPv6 address is 2001:ab5:0:1::160 so then >>>> >> > 2001:ab5:0:1::205 and 2001:ab5:0:1::160 appears in same network ? >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 11:40 PM Alberto Leiva <[email protected]> >>>> >> > wrote: >>>> >> >> >>>> >> >> Assuming that your IPv6 node network is 2001:ab5:0:1::/64, and >>>> >> >> pool6=2001:ab5::/96, then Jool's IPv6 address can be any >>>> >> >> 2001:ab5:0:1::X, where X does not equal 205. >>>> >> >> For example, 2001:ab5:0:1::201 >>>> >> >> >>>> >> >> Your IPv6 node needs to have either >>>> >> >> ip -6 route add default via 2001:ab5:0:1::X >>>> >> >> or >>>> >> >> ip -6 route add 2001:ab5::/96 via 2001:ab5:0:1::X >>>> >> >> >>>> >> >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 1:07 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> > please there is little more clarity require >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> > 1. As my IPV6 machine address is 2001:ab5:0:1::205 -->jool(ipv6 >>>> >> >> > should be address ?, its ipv4 address at one of NIC card is >>>> >> >> > 172.19.8.60)--->ipv4 node(172.19.8.12) >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 11:34 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> > <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> please there is little more clarity require >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> 1. As my IPV6 machine address is 2001:ab5:0:1::205 -->jool(ipv6 >>>> >> >> >> should be address ?, its ipv4 address at one of NIC card is >>>> >> >> >> 172.19.8.60)--->ipv4 node(172.19.8.12) >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 11:20 PM Alberto Leiva >>>> >> >> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> > 1. Right now my jool machine having same ipv6 address on its >>>> >> >> >>> > NIC card that is 2001:ab5...so first I will give it >>>> >> >> >>> > different one: suppose ffe8.... something . >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> Yes, but you don't need to go as far as to use ffe8. >>>> >> >> >>> Because your pool6 prefix is 2001:ab5::/96 >>>> >> >> >>> (2001:ab5:0000:0000:0000:0000::/96), you can use any other for >>>> >> >> >>> your >>>> >> >> >>> IPv6 nodes network (for example, >>>> >> >> >>> 2001:ab5:0000:0000:0000:0001::/96) >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> > 2. prefix will remain 64:ff9b::/96 at jool >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> If you change the prefix to ffe8:: or 2001:ab5:0:0:0:1::, you >>>> >> >> >>> don't >>>> >> >> >>> need to do this. >>>> >> >> >>> But if you want to leave your IPv6 node with 2001:ab5::, then >>>> >> >> >>> pool6=64:ff9b::/96 is a good idea. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> > 3. finally at IPV6 node I will add following cmd >>>> >> >> >>> > ip -6 route add <ffe8....//that is jool machine IPv6 >>>> >> >> >>> > address>/<prefixlength> via < 64:ff9b::/96 > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> It should be the other way around >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> ip -6 route add 64:ff9b::/96 via <ffe8....//that is jool >>>> >> >> >>> machine >>>> >> >> >>> IPv6 address>/<prefixlength> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> This command means "The 64:ff9b::/96 network can be reached via >>>> >> >> >>> <the >>>> >> >> >>> translator>". >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> > + Also what about when packet will return from ipv4 machine ? >>>> >> >> >>> > as jool ipv4 address should be different from ipv4 node , also >>>> >> >> >>> > ? same scenario as was with ipv6 network ? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> Have you read this? >>>> >> >> >>> https://jool.mx/en/intro-xlat.html#stateful-nat64 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> The IPv6 nodes and the pool6 prefix are supposed to be separate >>>> >> >> >>> networks. >>>> >> >> >>> But the IPv4 nodes and the pool4 addresses can be the same >>>> >> >> >>> network. >>>> >> >> >>> But if they aren't, you simply need to adjust your routing to >>>> >> >> >>> make >>>> >> >> >>> them reachable to each other. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 12:48 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> > Also what about when packet will return from ipv4 machine ? >>>> >> >> >>> > as jool ipv4 address should be different from ipv4 node , also >>>> >> >> >>> > ? same scenario as was with ipv6 network ? >>>> >> >> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 11:15 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> > <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> + Also what about when packet will return from ipv4 machine ? >>>> >> >> >>> >> as jool ipv4 address should be different from ipv4 node , >>>> >> >> >>> >> also ? same scenario as was with ipv6 network ? >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 11:07 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> please clarify some point before I make change to my test >>>> >> >> >>> >>> machines if I might understand you correctly. >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> 1. Right now my jool machine having same ipv6 address on its >>>> >> >> >>> >>> NIC card that is 2001:ab5...so first I will give it >>>> >> >> >>> >>> different one: suppose ffe8.... something . >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> 2. prefix will remain 64:ff9b::/96 at jool >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> 3. finally at IPV6 node I will add following cmd >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> ip -6 route add <ffe8....//that is jool machine IPv6 >>>> >> >> >>> >>> address>/<prefixlength> via < 64:ff9b::/96 > >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> ///////////////////////////// >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> n Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 10:44 PM Alberto Leiva >>>> >> >> >>> >>> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> 1. You can change the jool prefix to anything, as long as >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> the IPv6 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> node's own address is not inside the jool prefix >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> If the IPv6 node thinks it's inside the jool network, it >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> will try to >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> find 2001:ab5::172.19.8.12 in its own network, fail at the >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> neighbor >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> discovery step, and never send the packet to the translator. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> 2. That's right. Unless you add the route `64:ff9b::/96 via >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> <Translator's NIC IPv6 address>` to your IPv6 node >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 12:10 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > Yes my connectivity is like 172.19.8.12 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > --->>>JOOL(ip:172.19.8.60 and prefix pool6 is >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > 2001:ab5::/96 ) ----->172.19.8.26 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > my point is >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > 1. should I change jool prefix to 64:ff9b::/96 ? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > *2.if I change then I will do ping6 64:ff9b::172.19.8.26 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > , it may cause not to transfer pkt as network is in >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > 2001:ab5:: as route? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 10:38 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> Yes my connectivity is like 172.19.8.12 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> --->>>JOOL(ip:172.19.8.60 and prefix pool6 is >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> 2001:ab5::/96 ) ----->172.19.8.26 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> my point is >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> 1. should I change jool prefix to 64:ff9b::/96 ? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> 2.if I change then I will do ping6 64:ff9b::172.19.8.60 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> , it may cause not to transfer pkt as network is in >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> 2001:ab5:: as route? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 10:26 PM Alberto Leiva >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> Your IPv6 node thinks it's directly connected to the >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> NAT64 network. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> This is incorrect; from the IPv6 node's perspective, >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> the NAT64 network >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> is supposed to be seen as a separate network which can >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> be reached >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> through the translator. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> For example, if your NAT64 network (pool6) is >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> 2001:ab5::/96, then your >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> IPv6 node's network is supposed to be something that >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> does not equal >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> nor contain that prefix. For example, >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> 2001:ab5:ffff::/96, or >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> 2001:ab5:ffff::/64. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 11:49 AM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > //IPV6 node///////////////////////////////// >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ip -6 route >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > 2001:ab5::/96 dev eth1 metric 1 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > fe80::/64 dev eth1 proto kernel metric 256 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ff00::/8 dev eth1 metric 256 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ff00::/8 dev vip_eth metric 256 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ping6 2001:ab5::172.19.8.12 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > PING 2001:ab5::172.19.8.12(2001:ab5::ac13:80c) 56 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > data bytes >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > From 2001:ab5:0:1::205 icmp_seq=1 Destination >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > unreachable: Address unreachable >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > From 2001:ab5:0:1::205 icmp_seq=2 Destination >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > unreachable: Address unreachable >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > From 2001:ab5:0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > //////////jool ////////////////////////////// >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > joolmachine configuration is below: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > root@ruckus-OptiPlex-390:~# ifconfig >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > enp2s0: flags=4163<UP,BROADCAST,RUNNING,MULTICAST> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > mtu 1500 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > inet 169.254.121.93 netmask 255.255.0.0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > broadcast 169.254.255.255 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > inet6 fe80::c9f1:a162:b3d2:dd0d prefixlen 64 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > scopeid 0x20<link> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > inet6 2001:ab5:0:1::160 prefixlen 64 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > scopeid 0x0<global> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ether 00:0a:f7:2d:67:3a txqueuelen 1000 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > (Ethernet) >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > RX packets 188310 bytes 36844700 (36.8 MB) >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > RX errors 0 dropped 4019 overruns 0 frame 0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > TX packets 721 bytes 75614 (75.6 KB) >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > TX errors 0 dropped 0 overruns 0 carrier 0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > collisions 0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > device interrupt 17 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > enp4s0: flags=4163<UP,BROADCAST,RUNNING,MULTICAST> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > mtu 1500 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > inet 172.19.8.60 netmask 255.255.255.0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > broadcast 172.19.8.255 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > inet6 fe80::e5b1:419e:3a28:c0c1 prefixlen 64 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > scopeid 0x20<link> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ether d0:67:e5:27:2c:f8 txqueuelen 1000 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > (Ethernet) >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > RX packets 2423774 bytes 1145177984 (1.1 GB) >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > RX errors 0 dropped 17073 overruns 0 frame >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > 0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > TX packets 3678434 bytes 2236049996 (2.2 GB) >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > TX errors 0 dropped 0 overruns 0 carrier 0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > collisions 0 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > //tcpdump at jool machinee//////////////////// >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > 23:06:34.523300 IP6 2001:db8:0:1::a55 > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ff02::1:ff00:a4: ICMP6, neighbor solicitation, who >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > has 2001:db8:0:1::a4, length 32 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > 23:06:34.721460 IP6 fe80::dc1e:55ce:e8ca:a59e.53119 > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ff02::c.1900: UDP, length 146 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > 23:06:34.832887 IP6 2001:ab5:0:1::205 > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > ff02::1:ff13:80c: ICMP6, neighbor solicitation, who >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > has 2001:ab5::ac13:80c, length 32 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > 23:06:35.283935 STP 802.1w, Rapid STP, Flags [Learn, >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > Forward], bridge-id 820e.68:9c:e2:71:94:00.8028, >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > length 43 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 9:52 PM Alberto Leiva >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> Looks fine. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> Now that I think about it, your stats are telling us >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> that your >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> translator is not actually receiving any IPv6 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> traffic. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> Does your IPv6 node have a route towards 2001:ab5::? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> Are you sure the IPv6 node knows to send 2001:ab5:: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> traffic towards >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> your translator? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> What's the output of your IPv6 node's `ip -6 route`? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> Are there any routers between your IPv6 node and >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> your translator? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 10:54 AM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > jool -i alpha1 pool4 display --icmp >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > +------------+-------+--------------------+-----------------+-------------+ >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > | Mark | Proto | Max iterations | >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > Address | Ports | >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > +------------+-------+--------------------+-----------------+-------------+ >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > | 0 | ICMP | 1024 ( auto) | >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > 172.19.8.60 | 61001-65535 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 9:12 PM Alberto Leiva >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > What's the output of `jool pool4 display`? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> Sorry, I meant `jool pool4 display --icmp` >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 10:37 AM Alberto Leiva >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > JSTAT_POOL4_MISMATCH:15 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > What's the output of `jool pool4 display`? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 9:55 AM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Hello Alberto, >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Thanks for your reply: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Below is the detail please help: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > 1. Try "2001:ab5::172.19.8.26" instead of >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > "2001:ab5:172.19.8.26" >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > 2001:ab5::172.19.8.26 I tried this only it >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > gives destination unreachable. while ping. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > 2. If you ping the jool machine's IPv6 NIC >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > from your IPv6 machine, does it work? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Yes it working . >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > 3. If you ping the jool machine's IPv4 NIC >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > from your IPv4 machine, does it work? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Yes it is also working >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > 4. What's the output of 'jool stats >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > display'? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > JSTAT_RECEIVED4: 15 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > JSTAT_POOL4_MISMATCH:15 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Thanks >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Kunal >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > ////////////////////////////////////////////////// >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 8:20 PM Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Hello Alberto, >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Thanks for your reply: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Below is the detail please help: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> 1. Try "2001:ab5::172.19.8.26" instead of >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> "2001:ab5:172.19.8.26" >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> 2001:ab5::172.19.8.26 I tried this only >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> it gives destination unreachable. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> 2. If you ping the jool machine's IPv6 NIC >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> from your IPv6 machine, does it work? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> If you ping the jool machine's IPv4 NIC from >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> your IPv4 machine, does it work? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 7:39 PM Alberto >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Leiva <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > test: I am trying to ping >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > 2001:ab5:172.19.8.26 from ipv6 machine >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> Try "2001:ab5::172.19.8.26" instead of >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> "2001:ab5:172.19.8.26". >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> What's the output of ping? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> If you ping the jool machine's IPv6 NIC >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> from your IPv6 machine, does it work? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> If you ping the jool machine's IPv4 NIC >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> from your IPv4 machine, does it work? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> What's the output of 'jool stats display'? >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> On Tue, Apr 21, 2020 at 6:24 AM Kunal >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> Chauhan <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > Hi Team >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > I need help to configure my jool machine >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > I have a jool machine with 2 NIC card , >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > I configure as per jool documentation >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > method I follow is iptable. >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > 1. created instance >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > 2. creat pool6 as prefix 2001:ab5::/96 as >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > my ip6 machine or network is in that >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > prefix or address >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > 3. created a poolv4 as 172.19.8.60 //this >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > my jool machine ip >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > test: I am trying to ping >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > 2001:ab5:172.19.8.26 from ipv6 machine >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > please HEPL >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > _______________________________________________ >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > Jool-list mailing list >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > [email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >>> > https://mail-lists.nic.mx/listas/listinfo/jool-list >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> >> > > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> >> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>>> > >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> -- >>>> >> >> >>> >>> Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >>> Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >>> Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >>> Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >>> E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >>> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> -- >>>> >> >> >>> >> Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> >> Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> >> Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> >> Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> >> E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> >> >>>> >> >> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> > -- >>>> >> >> >>> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >>> > >>>> >> >> >>> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >>> > Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >>> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >>> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >>> > >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> -- >>>> >> >> >> Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> >> Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> >> Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> >> Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> >> E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> >> >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> > -- >>>> >> >> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> >> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> >> > Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> >> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> >> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > >>>> >> > -- >>>> >> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> >> > >>>> >> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> >> > Mob:09813614826 >>>> >> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> >> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> >> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> > -- >>>> > Thanks with Regards! >>>> > >>>> > Kunal Chauhan >>>> > Mob:09813614826 >>>> > Mob:08860397903 >>>> > E-mail:[email protected] >>>> > >>> >>> >>> >>> -- >>> Thanks with Regards! >>> >>> Kunal Chauhan >>> Mob:09813614826 >>> Mob:08860397903 >>> E-mail:[email protected] >>> >> >> >> -- >> Thanks with Regards! >> >> Kunal Chauhan >> Mob:09813614826 >> Mob:08860397903 >> E-mail:[email protected] >> > > > -- > Thanks with Regards! > > Kunal Chauhan > Mob:09813614826 > Mob:08860397903 > E-mail:[email protected] > _______________________________________________ Jool-list mailing list [email protected] https://mail-lists.nic.mx/listas/listinfo/jool-list
