I'm not a jUDDI developer but this is not the right way to earn commit rights. With absolutely no disrespect for Kurt, its important that Kurt demonstrate his commitment to the project by sending patches and code contribs to this project BEFORE becoming nominated a committer and most certainly before being granted one. While support is wonderful and excellent (and critically needed) that does not justify being made into a committer. I don't see any public evidence of Kurt's code contributions .. if I just missed it all please help me see it.
I'm -1 on this as its not consistent with established ASF practices for committership. WS PMC: If I'm out of order please correct. Sanjiva. On Fri, 2006-10-27 at 10:45 -0400, Steve Viens wrote: > jUDDI Committers, > > I'd like to recommend that Kurt Stam be granted committer privileges > for jUDDI project. Kurt has been working to integrate jUDDI into the > JBoss portfolio and is very familiar with the jUDDI project and code > base. Kurt has demonstrated this through support of on the jUDDI user > and dev lists. > > +1 > > Steve > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
