I'm not 100% sure I understand your question, but let me give it a shot. First thing is to note why you're getting that MethodError. It's from the line
println(si in sdt1[i, [:BreakTime1, :BreakTime2]]) Define sdt1 as you do (I just copied into a Julia REPL) and set i = 1 to for the first iteration of the for loop. Then: julia> sdt1[i, [:BreakTime1, :BreakTime2]] 1×2 DataFrames.DataFrame │ Row │ BreakTime1 │ BreakTime2 │ ├─────┼─────────────────────┼─────────────────────┤ │ 1 │ 2016-04-13T10:00:00 │ 2016-04-13T12:00:00 │ julia> si = Dates.format([sdt1[i,:StartTime]:Dates.Minute(30):sdt1[i,:EndTime]], "HH:MM") WARNING: [a] concatenation is deprecated; use collect(a) instead in depwarn at deprecated.jl:73 in oldstyle_vcat_warning at abstractarray.jl:29 in vect at abstractarray.jl:32 while loading no file, in expression starting on line 0 11-element Array{Any,1}: "07:15" "07:45" "08:15" "08:45" "09:15" "09:45" "10:15" "10:45" "11:15" "11:45" "12:15" julia> si in sdt1[i, [:BreakTime1, :BreakTime2]] ERROR: MethodError: `start` has no method matching start(::DataFrames.DataFrame) in mapreduce_sc_impl at reduce.jl:194 in in at reduce.jl:377 So si is of type Vector{Any} but happens to hold strings. sdt1[i, [:BreakTime1, :BreakTime2]] is a DataFrame. What does it mean to ask if a vector is in a DataFrame? That's what's happening in your println; the `in` is just an infix operator of function in. 3-element Array{Int64,1}: 1 2 3 julia> 1 in x true julia> in(1,x) true julia> in(5,x) false I assume you get the MethodError of no method start because in(a,b) iterates over b, checking each element of b for equality to a. But DataFrames are not iterable in this way. (This part just a guess; look it up in the manual before telling your friends.) Anyway, to get output as from your R snippet, you could use a loop like the following: julia> for i in 1:nrow(sdt1), t in sdt1[:StartTime][i]:Dates.Minute(30):sdt1[:EndTime][i] if !(t in [sdt1[:BreakTime1][i], sdt1[:BreakTime2][i]]) println("$i $(Dates.format(t, "HH:MM"))") end end 1 07:00 1 07:30 1 08:00 1 08:30 1 09:00 1 09:30 1 10:30 1 11:00 1 11:30 2 07:15 2 07:45 2 08:15 2 08:45 2 09:15 2 09:45 2 10:45 2 11:15 2 11:45 I hope this helps!