> > Another problem with DHCP-relay is that, AFAIK, it causes _all_ dhcp > > packets in every interface to be punted. So some transit DHCP packet > > jetting through your router in unrelated interface gets punted. > > I find this most unsatisfactory, but of course we're 'only one who has > > complained about this'. > > Hi, > > I thought that was with bootp, not with dhcp-relay?
It definitely applies to dhcp-relay. We were trying out dhcp-relay pretty early, and found a ton of bugs. I believe our testing (and I'm sure others also) is what resulted in the "forward-snooped-clients" and "overrides allow-snooped-clients" configuration knobs. I agree that punting DHCP packets on unrelated interfaces is a pretty horrible way of implementing it. We have complained about this loudly and repeatedly. But so far no luck. Steinar Haug, AS 2116 _______________________________________________ juniper-nsp mailing list [email protected] https://puck.nether.net/mailman/listinfo/juniper-nsp
