https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=521007
Bug ID: 521007
Summary: Changing between some compositions doesn't correctly
update layer visibility
Classification: Applications
Product: krita
Version First 5.3.2.1
Reported In:
Platform: Microsoft Windows
OS: Microsoft Windows
Status: REPORTED
Severity: normal
Priority: NOR
Component: Dockers
Assignee: [email protected]
Reporter: [email protected]
Target Milestone: ---
Created attachment 192846
--> https://bugs.kde.org/attachment.cgi?id=192846&action=edit
Popup when opening the problematic project file
Something important before I get into that. I've only been using Krita for a
few months, so I don't have a huge amount of files to test this issue on. So
far only my latest work produces this bug, none of the others do. Some parts of
the issue are consistent, some don't always happen. I'll group the issues below
because they're very similar:
====================
Problem #1
====================
This is a consistent problem, happens every single time
--------------------
Steps to reproduce
--------------------
1. Apply composition 13, and then switch to composition 12 in this particular
project file
--------------------
Observed result
--------------------
Nothing happens visually on the canvas. On the layer docker you can see the
“Highlights” folder gets disabled but that doesn’t actually update the
presented image at all. If I export the file at this stage the exported image
will be incorrect as well; the highlights will be visible despite its layer
group being turned off
--------------------
Expected result
--------------------
The Highlights layer group should be disabled on the canvas in composition 12,
not just the layer docker. And when the image is exported, only those layers
should contribute to the overall picture that are enabled in the given
composition
====================
Problem 2
====================
This is an inconsistent issue, it doesn't always occur. I don't know what makes
it happen exactly besides moving between different compositions. What seems to
make this issue happen more often is switching between early or later
composition, such as the first few or around the 20th numbered compositions
--------------------
Steps to reproduce
--------------------
1. Move from composition 12 to 13, or 14 to 13
--------------------
Observed result
--------------------
The blue highlights on his neck are visible on top of the black headphones,
despite the fact that a mask for that headphones area of the blue highlights
layer is enabled in the Layer docker
--------------------
Expected result
--------------------
The mask that hides the blue layer from showing up in the headphones' area
should hide the blue layer content in that given spot
====================
Problem 3
====================
This is an inconsistent issue, but it happens more often than Problem 2. I
don't know what makes it happen exactly
--------------------
Steps to reproduce
--------------------
1. Switch from composition 06 to 05
--------------------
Observed result
--------------------
The Highlights layer folder is hidden in composition 05, yet it's still visible
at the top of his head, and on his shorts. The highlights on both of these
areas has a sharp horizontal cut-off which doesn't exist in the layers
themselves
--------------------
Expected result
--------------------
The Highlights folder's layers should be completely hidden in composition 05
====================
Problem 4
====================
This is an inconsistent issue, it doesn't always occur. I don't know what makes
it happen exactly besides moving between different compositions. What seems to
make this issue happen more often is switching between early or later
composition, such as the first few or around the 20th numbered compositions
--------------------
Steps to reproduce
--------------------
1. Move from composition 07 to 06
--------------------
Observed result
--------------------
The blue highlight mentioned in Problem 2 appears on top of the headphones
despite the mask for that area on the blue highlight layer being enabled. And a
yellow highlight appears on the headphones' shadow even tho a mask for that is
also enabled
--------------------
Expected result
--------------------
Both masks should hide the given blue and yellow highlights from the
headphones' area
====================
Additional notes
====================
• If I manually enable or disable the problematic layers, they all work as
expected. These issues only happen when I update the visible layers by
switching between the mentioned compositions
• When I open this particular project file, Krita shows a popup saying "Waiting
for image operation to complete" (see attachments). This only happens with this
file, none of my other ones
• Saving/exporting images from this project takes significantly longer than in
others. So far in my experience exporting a roughly 5000x5000 px JPG image took
about 1-3 seconds each. But in this file they take 15-20 seconds each. This is
true for manual exports, and bulk exports from the Compositions docker
• So far I believe this is the only project where a layer group has its
"pass-through" blending enabled (the brick wall icon) which may or may not be
related to the problem, I don't know
• I can provide the problematic project file to the devs if necessary but not
in public. Please if you have a private way to contact me, I can send the file
to you
• I recorded the problems in a short video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=phaS219uf_s
====================
Solutions I've tried
====================
• Purge unused image data
• Close the project and reopen it
• Close Krita and reopen the project
• Delete all compositions and start from scratch. The exact same issue persists
with the exact same set of layers
• Restart the PC and reopen Krita
• Manually toggle problematic layers and update compositions
====================
Software / OS version
====================
I observed the exact same issues on 2 different computers. They both only show
these problems on this particular project file
--------------------
System 1
--------------------
Windows 11 25H2 (26200.8457)
Krita 5.3.1 and 5.3.2.1 (both portable). The file was created and finished
using 5.3.1 portable
Intel Core i5-12600k (power and turbo limits removed)
2x16GB 3200MT/s CL16 RAM (KF432C16BBK2/32)
Powercolor 6900XT Red Devil (-5% undervolt)
B660 Aorus Master DDR4 (Rev 1.1)
--------------------
System 2
--------------------
Windows 11 25H2 (26200.8457)
Krita 5.3.1 and 5.3.2.1 (both non-portable)
Intel Ultra 7 265k
2x16GB 6400MT/s CL32 RAM (F5-6400J3239G16GX2-RS5K)
Processor's iGPU
ASRock B860 Pro RS WiFi
--
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.
