https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=482418
--- Comment #18 from Blazer Silving <[email protected]> --- I've kept the code updated and ready for anyone to build on local kwin, but yes there has been some pushback upstream. I'll try to summarize. ---- >From what I understand, the concern from maintainers are over global navigation shortcuts (Ctrl+Meta+Up/Down/Left/Right): the frame of reference changes with the Desktop Grid View being de-coupled from the global layout. As it were, this is kind of the point of the MR, and it works without additional handling. I explain it in this comment specifically: https://invent.kde.org/plasma/kwin/-/merge_requests/6922#note_1258983. That's where we're at. The change essentially goes against the designed 6.x behavior, where I (and I suppose most of y'all) preferred the 5.x Grid behavior. I've not-so-subtly tried to push for reconsideration on the developer Matrix channels, but I've worn out my welcome with this and other Overview proposals. The maintainers have been proactively bumping old work this week, so I reached out again today on Matrix to kindly ask what it would take to satisfy the concern on the nav shortcuts/gestures. Nate jumped in to spruce up a few things on the ticket, but we need to clear the logic with those that wrote it in the first place, or it will never fly. ---- The rest of the ticket conversation is bikeshedding over the user-facing option and can be skipped. I would strongly prefer to configure this as an on/off checkbox option, but the overwhelming response from the design team is to use radio buttons, which introduced some code complexity to handle them. At this point the label can be anything, I'd just like to clear the actual code change with the team. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are watching all bug changes.
