---- On Mon, 17 Sep 2018 11:19:59 -0700 Adriaan de Groot <gr...@kde.org> wrote ---- > This depends on the state change *to* NEEDSINFO having a comment or other > message that is sufficiently directive: "we need <x information> in order to > do > anything with this bug". Or, in general, we'd need to keep in mind that that > > state change needs to have a clear and explicit question towards the > reporter.
Yes, this is what we do. In fact, not only is it documented at https://community.kde.org/Guidelines_and_HOWTOs/Bug_triaging#Ask_for_any_missing_information, but Bugzilla actually makes it mandatory: you're not allowed to change a bug to NEEDSINFO without a comment. +1, in favor, especially if we can close them in an automated fashion. Closing bugs isn't as frustrating for filers as it used to be anyway, since if they ever show up again with new information, they can just re-open them. Nate
