A Dissabte, 29 de gener de 2011, Christoph Cullmann va escriure: > On Saturday 29 January 2011 14:04:42 Albert Astals Cid wrote: > > > > So this is why i think it's a no go, and why opossed ages ago > > > > already. > > > > > > Ok, so let's work on the issues, instead of declining it. Since > > > KTextEditor remains in kdelibs, why is kate 'special'? Why can't we put > > > it in extragear/utils ? > > > > As far as I understood Cristoph idea was have a kate repo somewhere but > > on release stage Dirk would distribute the things as they are > > distributed now, e.g. katepart would end in kdelibs, kwrite in kdebase > > and kate in kdesdk. So if we put it in extragear/utils we are "lying" to > > our translators and to people that might use svn as source for their > > packages, etc. > > No really. > > Actually my (or the kate teams) plan was: > > - remove Kate Part + App + KWrite from their current places > - keep ktexteditor where it is (to have BC+SC kept) and have a small copy > in kate.git to allow easier development (which I will keep in sync with > the REAL on in kdelibs > - have kate.git packaged as kate.tar whatever with kde releases
So the kate.git package will "conflict" with the kdelibs one as both will provide ktexteditor? Well, i guess you can have some smart cmake hackery to fix this issue (though i'm really oposed to duplicate code i won't block the transition because of that) > I have no problem to be moved to extragear, but I would like to remain in > the normal KDE SC release. > > And I don't see this as a special wish, given for example kdesdk will for > sure split anyway up, why is it a problem if kate splits out first? How > will other split modules be handled? I have no problem if kate stays in > the "kdesdk" group, if there is any or any other toplevel group. I not > insist on some toplevel "kate whatever" thing, just a place where the > kate.git can be and be packaged with the KDE release. Ok, misunderstanding from my side then, having kate.git inside extragear- devtools or maybe kde-runtime (since it provides kwrite and katepart that for me are "basics" especially katepart) totally works for me (and my l10n concern is vanished) Albert > > Greetings > Christoph _______________________________________________ Kde-scm-interest mailing list [email protected] https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kde-scm-interest
