On Wed, Oct 22, 2008 at 6:22 AM, St?phane T?letch?a <steletch at free.fr> wrote: > > ----- "Dan Dennedy" <dan at dennedy.org> a ?crit : > >> On Tue, Oct 21, 2008 at 1:15 PM, St?phane T?letch?a <steletch at free.fr> >> wrote: >> > I've tried mixing 4/3 dv files + 16:9 dvd files (yes, coming from a >> dvd, not DV files), and the dvd >> > files are shrinked badly. >> >> Please describe it better: scaling artifacts, incorrect aspect, too >> much black padding? >> Also, if you play just the DVD rip with inigo, how does it appear? > > In fact this seems exactly the same problem. The image is stretched > in inigo and kdenlive while it displays correctly with mplayer for instance. > > The deformation makes people look taller and thinner than what the are > (womens appreciate but the deformation does not limit to them...). > > I've created the project using a DV pal format (not wide), and using a mix of > 4:3 dv files and 16:9 film from a DVD cam recorder. > > Do you need more info? (screenshots ?)
OK, it sounds like the aspect of the wide DVD footage is distorted to squeeze the 16:9 to (nearly) entirely fill the 4:3 frame. You said the problem also appears in inigo, but I want to know if you played the kdenlive project file or just the 16:9 DVD video file. Also, here are some things to do to discover the source of the problem: 1.) Again, just playing the distorted file in inigo: inigo -profile dv_pal some.mpg 2.) Play the file using ffplay; does it look correct? 3.) Send the output of 'inigo some.mpg -consumer westley' 4.) Send the output of 'ffmpeg -i some.mpg' -- +-DRD-+
